You are a young officer working with the Municipal Corporation of an industrial city. The city was known for manufacturing ball bearings and auto parts. Most manufacturing units were small-scale units with very little production process automation. The units relied on manual labor, which was in abundance due to the villages close by. As the number of manufacturing units grew, the demand for labor increased, bringing in a steady inflow of laborers into the city. This influx of people into the town led to a mushrooming of slums and encroachments on the sidewalks. Once in a while, the Corporation conducted drives to clear out the slums, but after a time, the slums came back. The illegal slums had become an urban nightmare. You were given the responsibility of clearing out the encroachments and slums with the help of Police authorities. As you started the drive, you realized that the people living by the sidewalks were vulnerable compared to the slum dwellers. Many sidewalk dwellers had recently come to the city after selling their properties in their villages. Now if you drive them out, they have no place to go. Your heart went out to them, and you felt that your departmental action was inhumane, but your official responsibilities demanded stern impartial action. You are desperate to find a way to help the sidewalk dwellers without compromising your official duties. (a) What value conflicts do you notice in the above situation? (b) Can an administrator compromise the value of impartiality for empathy? Discuss. (c) What are the options available in the above situation? (d) Suggest viable solutions for tackling illegal slums and encroachments in urban areas. (Answer in 250 words)
Vishnu Sasikumar, AIR 31, 2023
The above case study shows the implication of unplanned urbanisation and unplanned migration leading to reduction in well being of the vulnerable sections of society.
(a) Conflict between multiple values
1. Value of duty consciousness vs Compassion and care. 2. Rule of law vs Benevolence - whether to remove the illegal dwellers or to allow them based on benevolence 3. Obligation to Department vs Obligation to welfare of poor. 4. Objectivity in evicting the people vs Subjectivity by taking note of their unique circumstances
(b) Can an administrator compromise impartiality for empathy
Impartiality forms a core value of a civil servant, helping in duty bound conduct without any fear or favour. Ensures that civil servant abide the Constitution and works for the well being of all.
However, the care ethics give leeway for civil servant to compromise impartiality to bring in empathy to ensure that unique circumstances and situations are taken care of. When a civil servant deals with a tribal, or a physically challenged person, same rules cannot be applied to them. Aristotle also terms it unjust to treat unequals equally. Therefore unique situations allow civil servant to place empathy over impartiality to ensure public good and welfare for all.
Empathy must not lead to empathy overload or else it would lead to unefficiency and flouting of rules.
(c) Options available
1. Evicting the illegal dwellers, doing my duty as per the rules. 2. Letting go of the duty by requesting someone else to do my duty to prevent crisis of conscience 3. Persuading the authorities to halt the eviction, finding them alternative rehabilitation measures and rehabilitating them.
(d) Viable solutions
There are both short term & long term viable solutions to deal with such scenarios.
Short term 1. Building rehabilitation shelters for the vulnerable to ensure shelter 2. Rand mapping and drone flying through DILRIMP to secure land rights of govt, deterring encroachments. 3. Provision of Housing (affordable) and quality services including sanitation through PM Awas Yojana, Jal Jeevan Mission. This ensures quality life. 4. Slum redevelopment through PPP model to facelift the slums (Dharavi model)
Long term 1. Rural infrastructure and economy development through MSMEs to prevent distress migration 2. Inclusive spaces as Smart cities & AMRUT mission to prevent slum development. 3. Eradication of caste, religious consciousness to prevent slum based ghettosation.
A long term planning which involves all the stakeholders can ensure sustainable urbanisation free from encroachment