Why do traditions in our society impede change? To what extent can social legislation be instrumental against old customary practices?
Vishnu Sasikumar, AIR 31, 2023
India being an old civilisation state has both traditions and modernity coexisting together, leading to frequent clashes. Thus to protect status quo, traditions impede change.
Traditions impeding change - reasons 1. Change seen as too radical. Eg live in relations 2. Seen as breaking and destablising Indian society. Eg - LGBTQ relations. 3. Changes can disrupt our social institutions Eg- intercaste marriage disrupts caste. 4. Breaks the dominance of the upper class and caste.
Thus to avoid the above said effects, traditions are used to impede the changes to maintain the society as it is.
To overcome traditions & bring in changes, social legislations are fruitful as they carry power of punishment, thus making people follow the rules.
Some social legislations overcoming traditions 1. Protection of Civil Rights Act 1955 bans tradition of untouchability 2. Article 14, 15, 16 promotes equality among all 3. Special Marriages Act 1956 promotes inter religion marriage, diluting religious tradition 4. Prevention of Atrocities against SC, ST Act protects the rights of SC, STs against traditions of discrimination. 5. Supreme court decriminalising same sex relations
However, these social legislations have some limitations
Limitations 1. Poor implementation by law enforcement due to caste loyalties, religion loyalties etc. 2. Misuse of the laws for vendetta- Eg SC observed increase in misuse of prevention of atrocities against SC, ST Act 3. Judicial pendency leads to denial of justice & social progress envisioned by these laws 4. Protests and resistance from people upholding traditions.
Way forward 1. Social & behavioural change among people to imbibe the social legislations 2. Delegating power to state government for region specific social legislations
Social legislations based on constitution must form the basis for social revolution to do away with traditions violating dignity & equality