What do you understand by "integrity-based civil disobedience"? Do you think a challenge to personal integrity can be a justifiable cause for responsible disobedience in civil services? Explain. (Answer in 150 words)
Vishnu Sasikumar, AIR 31, 2023
Integrity based civil disobedience means disobeying unjust laws. Integrity requires a person to disobey unjust laws just as integrity leads a person to obey just laws. Gandhiji's civil disobedience movement is an example of such disobedience.
A civil disobedience is justified when the root cause of suffering is injustice, when the methods are non violent and when there are no hidden agendas of the movement but simply to undo the wrong. Similar traits of responsible civil disobedience were given by Rawls.
Personal integrity challenge as a cause of justification for responsible disobedience in civil service can be justified. A person who values non partisanship, accountability, respect for constitution considers all of them as a part of integrity. When any of these are violated, it threatens the sanctity of civil services which can hamper its functioning. Thus at such junctures challenge to personal integrity can be justified.
However, looking from multicultural perspectives, a person's personal integrity values differ from culture to culture. They would be at odds with civil services values. A person coming from western societies would find it against his integrity to follow the chain of command which civil services follow. Therefore disobedience in civil service at such juncture isn't justified.
Challenge to personal integrity can be justified if the values challenged are universal and disobedience to challenge them would result in well being of all, without causing any harm to others, just like Martin Luther