Examine the tension between the right to contest elections and the need to uphold electoral ethics under the Representation of the People Act. Should there be a lifetime ban on convicted criminals? (Answer in 250 words)
Aryan Yadav, AIR 31, 2025
The Representation of People Act (RoPA 1950, 51) enacted under Art 327 to ensure a free & fair electoral process in India
Right to contest elections 1. Key part of any democracy is right to contest in elections 2. Crucial to ensure universal adult franchise (Art 326) 3. Upholds principle of political justice in preamble 4. Upholds right of people to chose their representative
Challenge of upholding electoral Ethics 1. Fighting the rising criminalization of politics (46% of Lok Sabha MPs have pending criminal cases) 2. Addressing declining political ethics Eg. Cash for query scandal in Lok Sabha 3. Abuse of political power → conviction rate of MPs is 6% v/s National average of 46% 4. RoPA only disqualifies those convicted for 2+ years & only temporary disqualification of 6 yrs 5. No disqualification for those undertrial even for henious crimes 6. Upholds retributive justice 7. Reducing growing influence of black money in politics → 93% of LS MPs have assets over 1 crore
Case Against Lifetime Ban 1. Against principle of rehabilitative justice 2. After serving time → convict is equivalent to citizen 3. Against principle of free elections in democracy
Way Forward 1. Ban on undertrials for henious crimes (ADR) 2. Parliamentary ombudsman to address ethical violations (NCRWC) 3. Special courts for quick disposal of cases involving politicians (NCRWC)