Topper Copies

The restrictions imposed under Article 293 of the Constitution on State borrowing powers, though constitutionally valid, may hinder fiscal autonomy of States and disrupt cooperative federalism. Discuss in the light of recent developments. (Answer in 250 words)

Aryan Yadav, AIR 31, 2025

Under Article 293, center can put restrictions on borrowing powers of states.

Kerala has recently moved SC to challenge this provision

Reasons for Art 293 1. Promoting fiscal discipline among states 2. Prevent excessive borrowing & potential debt crisis 3. Incentivizes states to pay back pending loans 4. Enables center to limit levels of public debt

Hinderance on Fiscal Autonomy of States 1. Reduces states power to fund various social schemes Eg. Case of Kerala 2. Seen as encroachment by center on state's powers Eg. Recent restrictions on Punjab 3. States already highly dependent on central devolution of funds by Finance commission (Art 280) 4. West Bengal govt accused center of politicizing powers by using it against opposition ruled states

Disruptions of cooperative federalism 1. Leading to increased disputes between centre & states 2. States wary of over centralization of powers 3. States resorting to off budget borrowings → poor fiscal discipline

Way Forward 1. Constitution of interstate council (Art 263) to address disputes (Sarkaria commission) 2. Creation of a fiscal council on lines of GST council to promote fiscal federalism (Parliamentary standing committee) 3. Increasing share of states in net proceeds of tax to 50% in 16th FC 4. Increase central grants to states under Art 275 (Punchi committee)

Balancing fiscal autonomy of states & fiscal discipline is crucial to ensure sustainable & inclusive growth in India