Topper Copies

The 103rd Constitutional Amendment Act, 2019 has introduced a new dimension to the principle of affirmative action in India. Critically examine its implications for the broader goal of social justice. (Answer in 250 words)

Aryan Yadav, AIR 31, 2025

The 103rd constitutional amendment act introduced reservation for Economically weaker sections (EWS) - upto 10% by amending Art 15 & 16

Positive implications 1. Affirmative action for poor households having income below 8 lakhs/annum 2. Ensuring substantive equality under Article 14 by providing support to EWS 3. Will help reduce high income inequality in India → Top 1% own 40% of wealth (OXFAM India) 4. Help address the lack of equal opportunities for EWS 5. Upholds principle of economic justice enshrined in preamble hence is in lines with constitutional morality (Manoj Narula case) 6. Will help enable economic mobility for poor by providing reservation in education

Negative Implications 1. Original purpose of reservation was social justice & not economic 2. Would lead to further demands for reservation well beyond 50% ceiling of Indira Sawhney case 3. Potential for manipulation by falsifying income statements of households 4. Exclusion of SC/ST/OBC from EWS reservation 5. SC/ST fear that income becomes main criteria for reservation Eg. SC recommended creamy layer for SC/ST in Davinder Singh case 6. The 10% cap has been questioned as arbitrary 7. Income criteria must be updated regularly to account for inflation

SC upheld 103rd CAA in Janhit Abhiyan case holding it to be a constitutionally valid method of affirmative action