The principle of impartiality may conflict with the need for compassion towards marginalized communities. Discuss in the context of civil services in India.
Aryan Yadav, AIR 31, 2025
In civil services, impartiality refers to acting/talking decisions bored on merit alone & not any personal biases.
Conflict between impartiality & compassion 1. During provision of relief after disaster => - Impartiality = Treating all equally - Compassion = Providing aid to most vulnerable first - [Eg] During COVID, vaccines were first provided to elderly & (compassion) 2. Crisis of conscience => ordered to carry out action which may harm vulnerable groups - [Eg] Order to demolish illegal slums via bulldozers (lack of compassion) 3. Impartial application of the laws & rules v/s compassion for marginalised - [Eg] Providing welfare to old woman who lost her ration card
Balancing the two 1. A code of ethics can help guide actions during ethical dilemmas (2nd ARC) 2. Affirmative action for marginalized communities is ethically justifiable (Difference principle of Rawls)
"Good governance is not just about rule of law but also rule of conscience" Hence public servants must maintain balance.