Topper Copies

The more we automate, the more human we must become.

Aryan Yadav, AIR 31, 2025

The more we automate, the more human we must become.

In his book 'Homo Deus', Noah Hariri describes a dystopian future where humans are completely replaced by machines which are 'god like humans' (Homo Deus), capable of doing everything humans do better than them. The advent of Neural Networks and transformers has led to rapid growth of Artificial Intelligence (AI) technology, making the haunting prophecy of 'Homo Deus' more and more closer to reality.

Automation began with the industrial revolution, ushering in an age of machine manufacturing. While initially, the industrial revolution created many new jobs, the new Industry 4.0 is based on automation. The culmination of this is seen in Chinese dark factories, operating without any humans at all! In the modern age, AI is bringing widespread automation not only to industry but various other sectors as well.

Hospitals have begun to adopt AI for diagnosis, as seen with oncology. AI by AIIMS for cancer diagnosis. Google's AI based AlphaFold's ability to predict protien structures is playing a key role in developing new medicine, automating research. In the education sector, jobs of teachers are being automated by AI agents such as Chat-4pt. Jobs of various government employees are being automated by adopting e-governance and integrating AI into governance with tools such as Bhashini AI. This automation is bringing with it a large scale loss of jobs. ILO estimates that around 75 million jobs face the risk of complete automation due to AI. This rapid automation has brought the huge risk of losing out on our humanity.

AI models are powered by neural networks, modelled after the human brain. Thinking this makes AI like humans is naive. It ignores the fact that humans are much more than just a brain in a skeleton. We possess a unique attribute of humanity which differentiates us from machines. AI based diagnostic models can't replace doctors because they lack the emotional connections with their patients. They lack empathy and responsiveness to a patients problems.

AI algorithms often contain inherent biases by design. Claiming decisions made by AI are 'objective' is an easy way to perpetuate such biases. The COMPASS algorithm adopted by US courts was seen to be more likely to tag a black person as a criminal based on historical data it was trained on. The very nature of AI makes it prone to manipulation. Since AI models are trained on user inputs, they can be manipulated by malicious users. This was the core of Grok-3 model which began to perpetuate Nazi propaganda after users fed it such information.

Another challenge with automation is the lack of accountability. Assigning human responsibility for actions of a machine are quite difficult. This question has been raised with the use of Lethal Autonomous Weapon Systems (LAWS), AI powered weapons capable of picking targets on their own. Who holds responsibility if an autonomous weapon system accidently hits a civilian? Such questions are difficult to answer when we give control over human lives to machines that lack any remorse for making mistakes.

The rapid adoption of AI by the government has raised ethical questions surrounding privacy and autonomy of individuals. In '1984' George Orwell describes an authoritarian regime, where an omnipresent dictator ('Big Brother') watches everyone all the time. The adoption of AI based facial recognition technology has brought the dystopia of '1984' too close for comfort. The Ethics of such a rapid automation are murky at best. Immanuel Kant in his categorical imperative put emphasis on respecting the dignity of humans and not treating them as means to an end. Yet, modern AI technology seems to do just the opposite.

What role can humanity then play in this rapid age of innovation? Firstly, is ensuring responsible development of new technology.

AI should be guided by humane principles such as empathy, respect for autonomy & privacy. The Asilomar AI Principles seek to be a guide for creating responsible and safe AI technology. Protection of the data & privacy of individuals is also crucial. The Digital Personal data protection act in India emphasises data localization, storage of data of Indians within India. This is an important step to prevent data colonialism, which is the appropriation of Indian user data by foreign firms.

Education guided by ethical principles can play a crucial role in building a humane future. Emphasis on creative thinking and critical reasoning on lines of the Socratic method will help prepare our youth for the future. Focus on development of emotional intelligence is crucial so as not lose our humanity. "It takes something more than intelligence to act intelligently." - Fyodor Dostoyevsky. This emotional intelligence seperates us from machines.

AI guided by humanity can help create a bright future for us. India's Responsible AI for social empowerment mission highlights this by putting AI to use for upliftment of underprivileged sections of society. To assign responsibility with AI use we must ensure AI acts with human input only. The X-AI mission seeks to develop open source, explainable AI hence avoiding the black box models in use presently that act as a shield from any accountability.

While acknowledging that automation will lead to loss of jobs, we must create systems to protect those who lose jobs. The OECD has released a framework where profits of AI firms are taxed to protect those who lose jobs hence ensuring fairness and justice.

Mahatma Gandhi termed science without humanity as one of his 7 sins. The current automation driven by profit motives with no sense of it's impact is exactly that sin of Gandhiji. Avoiding the dystopian future outlined by Noah Hariri and building a better future for humanity requires regulating AI technology, ensuring all the safeguards we have discussed. Ultimately humanity's future will be determined by the humaneness of those who regulate AI & those who build AI systems.

"Technology can be a force of good or bad. It is the human intention behind it that determines it's impact." - Satya Nadella