Topper Copies

You have recently joined as the Chief Executive Officer of the Water Supply and Sewerage Board in a metropolitan city of India. Recently, there was an incident where two poor people died while undertaking hazardous cleaning of sewers in a posh neighbourhood, housing top corporate honchos of the city. The preliminary report found that a few residents in the said neighbourhood employed private workers to clean the sewers without the knowledge of the local city administration. A complaint for causing death by negligence has been registered against the concerned residents as well as the private contractor through whom these poor people were employed to carry out the task. The complaint has come as a shock to the residents of the neighbourhood, most of whom never had a brush with the law before. During the investigation, the residents of the neighbourhood complained that the local administration has not been cleaning sewers for a long time, forcing them to hire private workers. You also come to know that there has been a confusion over the maintenance works in the city administration, with no resolution till date. The city administration, as a whole, has also been facing a shortage of funds to build the requisite infrastructure and provide protective gears to carry out the sewage cleaning work. In the meantime, the family members of the deceased have started pressurising the government for compensation and there has also been a media blitzkrieg blaming the apathy of the city administration for the incident and pressure to withdraw the complaints registered against the high profile residents of the neighbourhood. In light of the above situation, answer the following questions: (a) Identify the stakeholders involved in the case along with the associated issues. (b) Evaluate the options that are available to you in the given case. Which of these options will you choose and why? (c) What will be the long-term measures you will take to prevent such an incident from occurring in the future? (Answer in 250 words)

Nikita Verma, AIR 30, 2025

The above case represents the instance of manual scavenging undertaken by a private contractor, in the absence of any safeguards against the law. In such a case, the rich and powerful neighbourhood engaged in hiring and continuing such practices.

(a) Stakeholders and Ethical issues involved 1. Residents of neighbourhood -> violated the law and are now facing consequences of administration's failure to perform their duties 2. Private contractor -> violated the law; lack of awareness of Prohibition of Manual Scavenging Act, 2013 3. Family of deceased: waiting for Justice 4. Law Enforcement Agencies: Failure on their part, as they couldn't check the violation of law 5. City Administration: non performance of duty; lack of funds 6. Media: maintain objectivity; not blame administration without knowing the facts 7. CEO of Water Supply and Sewerage Board: main issue is to establish justice; responsibility of maintenance work & provide justice

(b) As CEO, I have the following options

Option 1: Set a Committee for detailed enquiry + provide immediate compensation to families - Merits: punish guilty; rule of law upheld; uphold professional integrity; monetary support to deceased; administration is compassionate to vulnerable - Demerits: time consuming; mounts public pressure; puts unnecessary pressure from higher officials.

Option 2: Suspend officers who failed to provide timely services to residential neighbourhood - Merits: remove apathy among officials towards timely resolution of disputes; public/media pacified - Demerits: contrary to objectivity; lack of funds; lack of infrastructure & equipment

Option 3: Engage local police, file an FIR - Merits: uphold rule of law as per Prohibition of Employment as Manual Scavengers - Demerits: will face ire of media and residents; more public backlash

Course of Action = Option 1

Reasons: 1. Enquiry brings facts of the case. In case of dereliction of public duty, officers will be suspended. It would be easier to pursue case against residents 2. Ensure rule of law and values of integrity, neutrality, fairness while performing my duty. 3. Immediate monetary compensation ensures loss of income is substituted 4. NGOs, trusts, corporates - to be roped in for setting up dedicated funds for building infrastructure

(c) Long term measures to prevent such occurrences 1. Create awareness on Prohibition of Employment as Manual Scavengers & their Rehabilitation Act, 2013, along with impacts of manual sewage cleaning. 2. Build infrastructure. 3. Adopt technology 4. Skill workers