You are one of the producers of a television reality show. The show is very popular in the country and has a wide viewership among all sections of the society and across various regions. However, a controversy has emerged wherein in the latest season of the show, a contestant from the film industry who has been accused of sexual harassment by many of his co-workers has been accepted as a participant. Several media houses have reported it and have criticized the show for giving a national platform to one of the country's most high-profile alleged perpetrators of female harassment. They term it as a denigration of those women who had bravely spoken up about their harassment. In a personal capacity, you also feel the same and are of the view that such a controversial person should not have been invited to the show. However, when you talk to other producers about it, they opine that the controversy is good for the show, as it generates free publicity. Also, they say that a person is not guilty unless the court of law declares so and the career of a person should not be sabotaged due to media trial. Moreover, the person in question is very close to the host of the show, who is an extremely popular public figure in the country. The show commands a huge fandom and success of the show is also contingent on him. None of the producers want to antagonize the host. In the given situation, answer the following questions: (a) What are the ethical issues involved in the case? (b) What are the options available to you and what will be your course of action? (c) Discuss the positive and negative impacts of trial by media in such cases. (Answer in 250 words)
Nikita Verma, AIR 30, 2025
The above case study highlights the issue of a public figure who has been accused of sexual harassment at workplace by his co-workers, and has been invited to a reality show. In a bid to get TRP, producers are happy to bring him, however, it has questioned the moral-ethical dilemma involved.
(a) Ethical Issues in the case 1. Victims at unease: Given the person accused of a heinous crime will be present on National Television, it is disrespecting all women who have faced discrimination 2. Poorly on public moral: Publicity creates disillusionment among women's issues. It shows a poor state of morality 3. Mockery of Justice: It sends a signal that powerful and socially well connected can get away easily. 4. Patriarchal nature of society: where a man enjoys protection, and women are subjected to stigma. 5. Legitimacy to criminals while delegitimising movement - It sends a signal that rich and powerful can get away with crimes, and not the system.
(b) Options available & course of action 1. Stay silent - and allow the accused to be part of show 2. Raise concern/displeasure with higher management 3. Let Rule of law take its course 4. Meet the host of show and persuade him to convince the accused to withdraw from show.
Course of action 1. Meet all producers, persuade them to remove him from the show 2. Try and convince the host by presenting facts on the table. 3. Call meeting of all stakeholders to ensure accountability 4. Public show which is very popular in country, should adhere to the moral standards of the society.
(c) Pros/Cons of Trial by Media
Pros - Effective reporting helps in bringing the issues in front of the Nation - It helps in pressurising other stakeholders - civil society, government authorities, judiciary - to come into action.
Cons 1. Affects Judicial functioning: It prevents fair trial and is often driven by ill-informed, biased agenda driven debates 2. Fake vs Real: The media prevents presentation of facts with clear reasoning 3. Sensationalisation & Raise TRP: Often the media raises concerns to boost viewership, create sensations out of victims. 4. Instigate hatred and violence: The continuous display of victims and criminals tends to create divisions based on race, gender etc.
To prevent any miscarriage of justice and ensure fair trial, it is essential that media should engage in 'journalism' and not as a special agency for trying victims. They constitute the watchdog of civil society and should refrain from acting partially.