In order to tackle climate change, green energy is touted as one of the best solutions. Countries are now replacing coal with hydroelectric power, fossil fuels with solar energy, petrol and diesel cars with electric vehicles (EVs). EVs are being pitched as a cleaner, greener and sustainable alternative. Electric cars use batteries, and lithium and cobalt are rare metals that make up these batteries. The cobalt in the battery keeps it stable and allows it to operate safely. Cobalt is used in about half of the electric cars, which is about four to 30 kilograms per battery. You are the District Magistrate of a district where cobalt is found in abundance. On a visit to one such cobalt site, you find out that children are employed in the mines and these children flirt with death daily. They enter vertical tunnels that are too narrow for adults to enter and dig for cobalt under inhumane conditions in a furnace-like environment. Although, they sometimes use shovels, they typically dig with their bare hands. They are not provided with masks, gloves, work clothes and are only provided with 20 minutes of oxygen at a time. Yet, these young children dig for hours. Upon digging the rock, they crush it, wash it and then take their finds to the market in order to sell them. In this regard, answer the following questions: (a) Discuss the ethical issues involved in the above case. (b) Despite the legal and institutional measures, discuss the reasons behind the prevalence of child labour in India. (c) In context of the given situation, what steps will you take to address the issue of child labour in the district? (Answer in 250 words)
Nikita Verma, AIR 30, 2025
The present case presents that mining often involves employing child labour in inhumane conditions. Further, the move towards 'green energy' based on EVs like cobalt is being done in a wrong, unsustainable manner and is against SDG 3 - Good Health and well being, and Article 23 of the Constitution.
(a) Ethical issues involved in case 1. Child labour: forcing children into unhealthy working conditions; damage to their eyes, lungs; destruction of their immune system. 2. Unethical & Illegal working condition done by Miners:- against law, but continued for mere profits; big companies legitimising profits and greed. 3. Constitutional spirit: Article 23 prohibits child labour; Art 51A of Constitution provides for early childhood care; Article 21A gives Right to education. 4. Government Failure: unable to enforce the laws related to child labour; unethical child labour practices continue in society.
(b) Reasons for continuance of child labour Despite legislations like the Prevention of Child Labour Act, 1987 and the National Child Labour Policy, 1987, child labour continues as:- 1. Poverty -> absence of alternative sources of employment, children engage in labour to sustain their families 2. Social backwardness: Mining affected areas are the most backward region in terms of infrastructure, health and access to basic amenities. 3. Non availability of schools: In absence of any schooling, they are forced into manual labour. 4. Poor compliance and ineffective law and order:- in districts that are rich in minerals 5. Cheap labour: child labour is often a cheaper alternative to adult labour.
(c) Steps I'll take as DM 1. End vicious cycle
- Provide social assistance scheme - Access to poverty alleviation schemes.
2. Cash transfer - to poor families 3. Skill Development schemes to be introduced 4. Funds to be invested in R&D to develop technology driven solutions 5. Revamp educational infrastructure by providing access to schooling 6. Raise awareness in society of potential evils of child labour. 7. Penalise the industry - a move towards environmental friendly technology shouldn't come at a cost of child labour. Industries need to be persuaded to invest in technology and not engage in illegal activities. Damage to families needs to be done as per law and a strong precedent should be set.