You are the District Magistrate of a district, which is the hub of coaching centres for engineering as well as medical entrance exams. Recently, around 5 students have committed suicide owing to academic and social pressure. Students in the age group 15-18 years from across the country come to the district with the dream of getting admission into prestigious institutions like the IITs and AIIMS. However, the coaching institutes are business-minded and want to have toppers from their institute so that they can attract more students. They create a lot of pressure on students to perform, with differential treatment like forming different category of batches depending on students' performance. These students live as Paying Guests and in hostels away from their families and many cannot tackle the huge burden of competition and the associated mental stress. The recent spate of suicide by 5 students has been highlighted by the national media and you have been asked by the Chief Minister to present a report of the situation and take steps on the matter. The Chief Minister has also asked you to keep the matter away from limelight so that the coaching centres continue with their business and generate revenue for themselves as well as the state. Upon investigation, you find out that 2-3 of the most famous coaching institutions are run by political leaders of the ruling party. They are involved in false advertisements in order to lure students. They also create undue pressure on the students to perform. Also, there is an emerging black market for performance enhancing drugs, which have become common among the students. Given the situation: (a) Highlight the stakeholders involved and discuss the associated ethical issues in the given case. (b) Given the situation, what will be your course of action? (c) Discussing the various reasons for increased cases of suicides among students, suggest measures to address the issue in the long-run. (Answer in 250 words)
Nikita Verma, AIR 30, 2025
The above case represents the case of the 'education system' in India. Over-emphasis on rote-learning, performance orientation and thriving "coaching culture."
In the absence of holistic, all round development (emotional, psychological, physiological well being), we have growing instances of:- - Anxiety, stress - Depression - Lack of Motivation - Drug Abuse - Isolation - Extreme cases - suicide among youth.
(a) Stakeholders and Ethical Issues 1. Students - overburdened with academic and social pressure. - restlessness, pushes them into drug abuse - being robbed by coaching institutes -> false results 2. Coaching Institutes - Greed driven institutes = to generate profits - Deceit by generating false advertisements - Purporating unhealthy competition 3. Paying Guests & Hostels - unsupportive, don't live upto their promises - dismal services 4. District Administration & Myself - ensure Justice to victims - address the unethical coaching business flourishing - to choose between professional integrity & personal commitment 5. Political Parties: Involved in coaching business - aim at profit maximisation. 6. Parents/Family: Putting their children under undulating pressure to perform. 7. Government & CM: Instead of addressing issue, asks to hush the matter. Thus, indicating collusion.
(b) Steps I'll take as a DM 1. Setting up police enquiry -> to curb spread of drugs around coaching institutes 2. Enquiry into unethical practices undertaken by coaching institutes -> punish accordingly 3. Guidelines for coaching institutes:- compulsory provide mental health practice; setting up counselling centres; generate free helpline number for distressed individuals 4. Mandatory career counselling sessions aimed at: a) showcasing alternate institutions other than IITs & AIIMS; b) other fields of service - commerce and liberal arts 5. Awareness among parents of alternate measures, sustainable efforts. 6. Sensitising PG facilities and hostel campuses.
(c) Various reasons for increase in suicides among students 1. Unsustainable goals: Engaging in 12-14 hours of studying without giving sufficient time to health, social belongingness and family. 2. Isolation - driven by toxic culture of "cut throat competition" in centres 3. Social pressure - of family and relatives to perform. 4. Lack of Guidance - in an environment where adolescents (15-18 yrs) stay away from parents, their loved ones, they find no one for effective mentorship. 5. Narrow perception of "success" - singularly stressing on career related growth while neglecting other aspects.
In the given situation, the education system needs an overhaul - a move away from marks-oriented coaching centres to holistic school based education - emphasising both circular & co-curricular.