You are a young IAS officer and have recently joined as a Sub-Divisional Magistrate in a district, which has been declared 'open defecation free'. However, you get information that some villages in your sub-division are still continuing the practice of open defecation out of habit despite availability of toilets. Your colleagues in the district administration confirm that the information is true. You call the village headmen of these villages and tell them to persuade their respective villagers to stop open defecation. But, they express their unwillingness and inability to fully stop this practice, as in some cases they themselves consider it healthy to defecate in the open. You discuss this matter with the District Magistrate who forbids you from taking any official action, as this may cause the 'open defecation free' status given to the district to be withdrawn. As a young and dynamic officer, answer the following: (a) Why do people continue to practice open defecation even when they have access to toilets? (b) What are the options available to you as the Sub-Divisional Magistrate in this case? Highlight the merits and demerits of each option. (c) What will be your course of action? (Answer in 250 words)
Nikita Verma, AIR 30, 2025
The above case represents the practice of defecating in open despite availability of latrines, in an ODF district. It highlights that behavioural change is difficult to achieve and requires continuous efforts.
(a) Reasons for continued open defecation 1. Age old practice - Open defecation is widely practiced in villages across India - Part of regular routine 2. Unscientific religious beliefs: Belief that households are pure - residence of Gods - where dirty activities are not to be performed 3. Resistance to change: communities are close-knit and are categorically against any new practice. 4. Hygiene issues: Many consider latrines as a source of filth and disgrace. Thus, prefer open defecation.
(b) Options available and their analysis
Option I - No action - Merits: Maintains status quo; Award of ODF preserved; don't upset DM; villagers continue practice - Demerits: Promotes unhygiene; Moral dilemma for me; Backseat to spirit of service; village may become centre of disease
Option II - Take official action against villagers - Merits: check open defecation; punish the wrongdoers; establish order - Demerits: Disrupt relations with DM; Damages faith of villagers; status of ODF in danger.
Option III - Active Persuasion, Incentive, Role Modelling - Merits: curb open defecation; maintain trust of DM; help bring positive social change - Demerits: Difficult, tireless efforts; mayn't be effective in bringing behavioural change
(c) Action as an SDM 1. Active persuasion -> involves explaining the merits of using safe hygiene, and the demerits of going for open defecation:- Typhoid, diarrhoea and other women centric diseases 2. CAB Model (Cognitive - Affective - Behavioural): scientific data such as NFHS data (2007-2011) on deaths associated with unsafe hygiene; giving priority to elders and children; rewarding families/farmers -> easy access to credit if have toilets 3. Nukkad Natak, Jan Bhagidari for people's participation 4. Gram sabha to popularise the idea of toilets at home 5. Screening of movies like 'Toilet: Ek Prem Katha' 6. Role Modelling -> involving sanitary workers, doctors, social workers, leaders, panchayats, myself to actively use 'toilets'.
Behavioural change is a long drawn out process which can be addressed through systematically identifying: 1. Target population 2. Effective Methods.