True leadership lies in serving not ruling.
Nabiya Parvez, AIR 29, 2025
True leadership lies in serving not ruling
"The two road diverging in a wood, I take the one less travelled, That has made the all difference." These lines by Robert Frost, highlights the two different approaches, one the "path of ruling" which is choosen by everyone in their leadership journey, and the second one - the less travelled - is the "path of serving".
Leadership the position which was is hold by the person, who is at the top of the hierarchy due to knowledge, strength, power etc. to rule or govern. But the true leadership is the positive where serving is the ultimate aim of the leader.
In Ancient times, leaders were king, as chanakya said "The king's happiness lies in the happiness of his subject", where leaders serve the society, as reflected in the actions of the Ashoka, where he left the violence by choosing the path of dhamma, the finest example of ruling to serving transformation.
Similarly in Medieval times, the religious tolerant, and the one who acknowledged diversity, formulates policies to serve the people rather to rule over them, he is none other than the Akbar, reflects in his philosophy of Sulh-i-kulh, Diwan-i-aam meetings etc.
True Leadership: The Evolution
In Ancient and Medieval times leaderships were hereditary, followed the monarchial pattern, where ruling and serving become synonyms due to the lack of understanding at that time, but we have seen the finest examples of their times in the name of Ashoka and Akbar.
Evolution of leadership rather the true leadership started after the period of enlightenment when people understood the meaning of 'true leadership' is not 'to rule' but 'to serve'.
When Mandela came out of the prison and on his way to take the oath as the President, asked by reporter - what his purpose as a leader? he replied, to serve the people.
To serving the society is not a static concept, it keeps on evolving with time. From simply listening the grievances of the people, understand their plights, these are the basic foundation pillar of serving - as evident from our late former Prime Minister, she used to organised 'Janta ka Darbar' at her residence.
True leadership is not only limited to politics of the country but each and every person is the leader in itself, they serve the society in their own way.
Discovery of Penicillin by Alexander Flemming during the world war was changed the entire field of medical sciences, he did not file any patent for this, allowed the mass production and distribution of his hard earned discovery, here he choose the path of serving over the path of ruling.
Attributes of True leadership
First Greek legends odyssey and Iliad defined leadership through the character of the person, where the right character sow the seed of true leadership.
In 1960s, Lal Bahadur shastri, then Prime Minister of India, skipped the one time meal, when country was facing food shortages due to two fronts war with Pakistan and china. His path of serving was self-sacrifice.
Similarly, the another attribute lies in the attitude to alleviate the suffering of others, Rafia Ali, an innovator of break free stories, where she organised camps for the divorcees and deserted women, her definiation of 'serving' is reducing the pain in the lives of others.
After seeing the attributes, let us understand the meaning of 'ruling', Is it always bad? or something else is making it notorious.
The concept of ruling is as old as the human existence, the ruling class of Dryopithecus, an early human ancestor revealed the hierarchial and ruling setup.
'To Rule' the people is important to prevent them from chaos, as given in our constitution under Article 14, where it is written 'Rule of Law' must be followed, and no one is above the law.
'Ruling' can be understood to prevent the people from distress through sometimes it requires harsh measures like strict isolation policy during covid-19 pandemic across the globe.
If everything is good about the ruling then why the evolution of true leadership demands the 'concept of serving'?
When leaders become the owners and their ruling becomes the cage, as evident from the Aristocratic rule in Iran, where death of Mahsa Amini, revealed the harsh 'ruling' of the regime.
Similarly on the another side of the kim kingdom in North Korea, where people even don't understand the difference between 'serving' and 'ruling'.
Here we get the answer that why true leadership demands serving over ruling. As very well said by Lincoln - Leaders are not born, they are made. They are made by the society in which they are living, shaped by the education, similarly true leadership is also made by the society, for the society and to the society.
The Way Ahead
Lord Krishna tells Arjuna, the king must detach himself from personal connections to serve the kingdom in any phase and at any cost. similarly, philosophy of Buddhism explained the true leadership concept - as the one who promotes inclusivity, acceptance to variety of ideas.
Inculcation of values in leader helps him to transformed into true leader, India is blessed with these values, as reflected in our core philosophy of vasudhaiva kuttumbakam - where world is one family, should be governed in best ethical way to serve the world.
Apart from religious and value based teachings, experimental studies can be done, using leadership performance chart which the score is providing on various indicators and among all major weightage is given to 'serving'.
True leadership is not all about leaders but the citizens as well, as rising 'criminalization of politics', 'low women participation' and 'low voter turnouts' showed the declining faith in leadership. This needs to be corrected.
This can be done by door to door campaign by the leaders with their leadership performance chart, to encourage them for their valuable participation and make the whole system more inclusive.
As I have written earlier, we all are leaders in our lives, we must serve the country by raising our voices against injustice, cruelty etc to be, as evident during Nirbhaya Rape case agitation, R.G Kar college incident.
'Serving' and 'Ruling' are not on the two opposite poles, they are the two parallel axis which are lying next to each other, like two roads, these two parallels must be merged together into one path.
By this, person don't have to choose between the two diverging road as given by Robert Frost, rather he has only one path, which will not be less travelled, rather, it will be travelled by everyone to become the true leader.