Topper Copies

Mr. A is travelling by road with his family to attend a marriage ceremony. His grandfather, who is the head of the family, is also travelling with him. On the way to their destination, all of them stop at a roadside restaurant for lunch. This is a well-known restaurant owned by one of the friends of Mr. A. The place is known for its tasty and hygienic food. However, the grandfather notices a picture on the wall of the restaurant and enquires about the religion of the restaurant owner. Mr. A's friend belongs to a religion different from his grandfather's religion. The grandfather has a negative attitude towards the religion of Mr. A's friend, and he insists that he will not eat in that restaurant. He demands that the entire family leave the restaurant immediately, as they are travelling for a happy occasion and eating at this particular restaurant will pollute them. Mr. A tries to calm down his grandfather and explain to him that religion has nothing to do with purity or pollution. He also reasons that several travel magazines have rated the restaurant highly, especially for its superior hygiene standards. Also, he points out that there is no restaurant in the way for the next 100 km, and it will be difficult for all to make do without food for that long. However, his arguments fall on deaf ears, and more specifically, his grandfather admonishes him for bringing the family to the restaurant despite being aware of the religion of the owner. Mr. A's friend feels insulted and discriminated against due to his religion. Mr. A's father is upset but refuses to say anything out of respect for the grandfather. The entire family is embarrassed by the attitude of the grandfather, and they are getting ready to leave the restaurant. Mr. A is confused regarding how he should act in this situation. What are the various ethical issues in the above case study? Imagine yourself in the place of Mr. A. Evaluate the different courses of action available to you. What is the most suitable course of action?

Bhavika Chopra, AIR 25, 2025

This case study deals with the issue of a prejudice impacting Mr. A's grandfather's attitude towards a particular religious community.

(a) The ethical issues involved in the case are 1. Discrimination by A's grandfather on basis of religion. 2. Mr A's friend feeling insulted - may sour their friendship. 3. Against constitutional principles and constitutional morality. (fraternity among citizens)

However, this instance refers to a larger issue pervasive in India - for which the Supreme Court recently passed a judgement stating that restaurants may choose not to display the name of the owners to prevent religious discrimination.

(b) As Mr. A, the following courses of action are available

1. Agree to grandfather's request and not eat at restaurant.

PROS | CONS --- | --- Keeps peace in the family | 'A' compromises on personal values Respects grandfather and is a dutiful grandson | Sours relationship with friend Grandfather's admonishment retains his authority and respect | Indulges in religious discrimination implicitly; sets wrong precedent for family and society at large.

2. Be adamant about eating at the restaurant and not compromise.

PROS | CONS --- | --- Upholds personal principle | Is a tactless approach Upholds larger constitutional principles of non-discrimination | May cause a rift in the family Sets a good precedent for society. | May be seen as disrespectful towards grandfather.

3. Ensure grandfather about hygiene and cleanliness; be stern and clear on stance against discrimination without being disrespectful.

PROS | CONS --- | --- Upholds his principles without being rude | May be a difficult talk to convince grandfather for a longer duration Stays calm in his dealings; maintains his bond with friend |

Hence, in this 'dharma sankat' where 'A's' duties as a grandchild and as a citizen cements conflict, he must choose the latter.

"There is no office higher than the office of a citizen"

Hence, the third option is the most viable one:

ACTION | REASONING --- | --- 1. Talk to grandfather and reason out the situation. | Prevents disrespect of elderly members. 2. Take grandfather to kitchen to ensure hygiene standards. | Use of logic and rationale to aid attitudinal shift 3. Compliance with duty as a citizen; being adamant about eating at restaurant for practical purposes too. | Ensures constitutional principles are upheld by the family; setting a good precedent.

Thus, Mr. A must risk facing his grandfather's ire in lieu of being party to religious discrimination. He must remain true to his personal principles and uphold constitutional morality.