You are working as Director (Human Resource) in a software company. Various factors such as economic slowdown in some of the major trade partners of India and disruptive technological changes like generative Artificial Intelligence require rapid adaptive measures from businesses to survive. The marketing department has reported that there is lack of demand for the services provided by your company in the market and business-as-usual scenario could spell doom for the company. Your company has decided to take a slew of measures to tread through a tough phase of the business which include technological rejuvenation of the company and streamlining the workforce. A significant number of employees in your organization are above fifty years of age and are finding it difficult to adapt to the new working conditions and the rapid upskilling required by the company. After proper training, the employees were subjected to a test, and a list was prepared of those who are above fifty years of age and who did not do well in the test. You have been told by the board of directors that they have plans to lay off approximately 25% of the employees. This is essential for the efficiency and survival of the company. You have been given a list of employees who are to be laid off and you have been told to communicate to them the decision of the company to terminate them. In the above list, there is an employee who has been working in the company for twenty years. He is known for his discipline, integrity, and loyalty to the company. His financial situation is not good at present as he applied for personal loan a few months ago in order to meet the expenses of his ailing father who was hospitalized. He is sole breadwinner of the family and has two dependent daughters. Marriage of one of the daughters is scheduled for next month. What are the ethical issues involved in the above case? As the head of the HR department, what ethical dilemma do you face? Do you think that the company's decision is appropriate? According to you what should have been the ideal course of action in the given scenario?
Bhavika Chopra, AIR 25, 2025
The aforementioned case study deals with technological disruption arising out of advance of artificial intelligence; besides the job market being disrupted by the fourth industrial revolution.
(a) Ethical issues involved in firing people from company
1. For company - Loss of significant talent pool - Lack of support to employees - May lead to loss of company's culture of work - Prioritising profits over people and employees. - Testing given priority over re-skilling
2. For employees - Mute bystanders -> victims to disruption of job market - Losses in finances, lack of job security - Larger issues of rising unemployment -> may lead to rise in poverty, indebtedness, domestic violence, crime etc.
3. For HR manager - Facing employees; caring about employees yet being helpless. - Being bound by company policy.
(b) As the head of the HR Department, one would face the following ethical dilemmas 1. Being bound by company directions v/s wanting to take a humane approach. 2. Company profitability v/s retaining loyal, hard-working employees. 3. Down-sizing operations v/s considering financial constraints of employee being fired. 4. Using a test as a metric to retain employees v/s their calibre, loyalty, values etc.
(c) In a capitalist, ruthless set up, the company's approach can be analysed
PROS | CONS --- | --- Works on pure merit basis | Overlooks loss to work culture Retains profitability of company | Loss of humane factors in Human Resource management Adjusts company to fourth Industrial Revolution | May lead to reputational, long term losses to company Maintains efficiency of operations. |
However, the way ahead can be outlined as below
Approach | Reason --- | --- 1. Engage in re-training of employees who did not do well on test. | Retains talent, retains work culture. 2. Diversify operations | Ensures profit generating activities stretch far and wide 3. Could subscribe to uniform salary cuts across designations. | Ensures young employees can earn from older employees -> humane and people centric human resource management. 4. Creation of partner system of old-young employees. | Integrating employees in company.
Therefore, a humane approach that ensures the delicate balance between people and profitability is maintained could be followed instead of efficiency and pure merit down-sizing.
In the movie "The Intern", one single aged intern changes the entire work culture of a place, improving functioning and efficiency of the company. Such values cannot be learnt via skilling; this must be retained via due importance in human resource management policy.