A gaming website dedicated to chess has gained popularity in recent times due to its online lessons and tips for improving skills in the game. You have recently started playing chess at the platform. The platform provides you analysis of your games and suggests areas of improvement. The online lessons have helped you improve your game a lot over a very short time. You are amazed at the ability of competing with players of all levels of skills from across the world. While testing and improving your chess skills on the platform, you have made friendship and acquaintances with many competitive chess players from different parts of the world. Recently, you have been encountering racial, religious and stereotypical remarks during the games from the other players. Initially you ignored such things as childish tactics by an opponent to distract you from your gameplay. Later you would try to engage with such people to dispel stereotypes. But increasingly such experiences are making you sad and bitter. Now you block such people as you encounter them. What started as a fun and stimulating experience for you has become a source of negativity in your life. In your discussions with other people, you come to realize that they have also experienced similar racial and religious slurs, and many people have left the platform to avoid the abusive experience. You also sense that this is not an issue specific to this gaming website but is part of the generally seen behaviour on social media. You used to consider online trolling as harmless puns that could not create actual harm, but after experiencing its dark side as a victim you are realizing its negative impact. Given this information, what are your thoughts on the following: How should one deal with the issues of on-line abuse such as in the case above? What options are available to you? What values should guide online behaviour? Do these values differ from values governing offline conduct?
Bhavika Chopra, AIR 25, 2025
The aforementioned case study deals with an instance of cyber-bullying which has impacted a players' mental well-being due to negativity impacting their experience of social media and online gaming.
(a) The options available in such an instance are
1. Continue engagement with the bullies and online trolls to dispel stereotypes
PROS | CONS --- | --- Will do bit to society | Developing a negative attitude towards life/people Promote inclusivity on the gaming fraternity; may change outlook for some people, may make them more compassionate | May impact chess game (skills etc)
2. Ignore the trolls, and quit the platform
PROS | CONS --- | --- Save mental health and prevent negativity | May be considered running away Not engage with draining people, focus on chess. | Will impact development of fortitude adversely
3. Engage in meaningful discourse and ignore the naysayers.
PROS | CONS --- | --- Would aid enhancing ones' world-view and inspiring small-scale change | Draining for people in gaming and on social media. Safeguard own mental space; engaging at own convenience - not running away from a problem | May receive even more trolling and negative experience.
People engaging in hurtful behaviour can do so because they sit behind a screen wearing a mask of anonymity, which gives them the courage to indulge in such behaviour.
To deal with issues of online abuse 1. Involve a close friend/family member. 2. Have a safe space for children to open up to parents. 3. Be non-resistant to report such behaviour to authorities and seek a legal recourse. 4. Dis-engage from social media and online gaming (virtual world) every once in a while.
(b) Values that should guide online behaviour are 1. Respect for fellow netizens. 2. Use of non-foul language. 3. Use of actual names (not anonymity shielding vile actions) on social media. 4. Code of behaviour by social media intermediaries and gaming platforms. 5. Grievance redressal mechanism against people/players violating norms and norms of propriety.
Online behaviour norms | Offline behaviour norms --- | --- Involve mostly text/speech cues | Involve bodily/behavioural cues Can be anonymous | Usually not anonymous Difficult to hold people accountable for text/speech | Easy to hold people accountable for behaviour Not guided by usual societal rules. | Guided by norms of societal constraint
Thus, even though these norms differ, the solution lies in: 1. Creating a grievance redressal and speedy resolution mechanism. 2. Social media etiquette education for users. 3. Suspension of accounts indulging in trolling/abusive behaviour.
Thus, at a personal level, one must guard their mental well being while being cognisant of the fact that abuses come from a place of inferiority compensation. At the institutional level, care must be taken to ensure that the virtual world retains its democratic and secure characteristics.