Topper Copies

Many proponents of deep-sea drilling argue that tapping into the vast amount of rare earth elements in the Indian Ocean will help shore up national security interests for India, bolster its economy and workforce, and offer a reliable supply of strategic minerals. Keeping this in mind, the government has approved a $540-million programme to study ways of mining nickel, cobalt, manganese and iron hydroxide from the bed of the Indian Ocean 6,000 meters below sea level. The government argues that the project can power India's growth for 100 years. It will also study climate change, explore marine flora and fauna and harness thermal energy. However, a competing point of view alleges that deep ocean drilling poses immense risk to the environment. A comprehensive report on Sustainable Ocean Economy by independent geologists states that "until the need for, and potential consequences of, deep-sea mining are better understood, the concept is conceptually difficult to align with the definition of a sustainable ocean economy and raises various environmental, legal and governance challenges, as well as possible conflicts with the UN Sustainable Development Goals." It also highlights that the profitability of national mining operations, without governmental support or comparably low taxes, remains questionable. If the operations are profitable, it will also raise questions about the equitable sharing of profits derived from a resource taken out of humanity's common heritage. Additionally, companies like BMW, Volvo, Google and Korean battery maker Samsung SDI, vowed in a statement to not buy metals produced from deep-sea mining until the environmental risks of the activity are "comprehensively understood." In the context of the above-stated information, address the following: (a) What are the ethical issues in the given case study? (b) How can the vision of economic development of a nation be achieved without adversely affecting the sustainability of oceans?

Animesh Pradhan, AIR 2, 2023

Universal Declaration of Human Rights have announced 'Right to healthy environment' as a human right, but various economic aspirations deplete the realisation of goal of sustainable living.

(a) Ethical issues in the case

1. Environment vs economy - tussle between environmental safety vs economic growth

2. National Interest vs ecological interest - the deep sea drilling has security, economic & geopolitical advantages for the nation, but have potential to harm the biodiversity

3. Crony capitalism - since the proceeds of the benefits will be largely appropriated by few drilling companies.

4. Erosion of constitutional goals of safe & protected environment - Article 48A, community participation (73rd & 74th Amendment) and equitable distribution of wealth (Article 39(b))

5. Disappointing big corporates like Samsung, BMW, Volvo who are committed for sustainable production & mining.

(b) Vision of economic development can be achieved without affecting oceans

1. Environmental Impact Assessment to judge the extent of damage and scope for rehabilitation. The EIA must be carried out diligently, suitably from a 3rd party auditor with track record of impartiality.

2. Social Impact Study to map the extent of rehabilitation & displacement of indigeneous coastal communities & make arrangements for material & non-material compensation.

3. Sustainable mining process with lower carbon footprint & less geomorphological damage to be utilised, & technology transfer from International collaborators.

4. Biodiversity protection - Ex displacement of corals colonies to safer location, scientific displacement of flora & fauna to a suitable location based on scientific prescription.

5. Pilot Drilling at a small scale to understand the impact and extent of social & ecological damage.

6. Strengthen laws like Environmental Protection Act, CRZ Regulation, Mineral Development Regulation with Bentham's maxim of "maximum benefit to maximum people".

7. Empower bodies like NGT and CPCB & INCOIS for vulnerability study & review.

Anand Mahindra notes, "sustainability should be a way of life to make sustainability a way of business".