You have recently been posted as a Nodal Education Officer in one of the districts, where mass cheating in examinations is a regular phenomenon. Media reports have shown parents and relatives scaling school walls and buildings to pass answer chits to students taking secondary school examinations in the district. Moreover, with the advent of new technological devices, cheating in examinations has become more sophisticated and exam rules are flouted openly. On investigation, it has come to your notice that these rackets are run by many school authorities, including exam invigilators who are mostly teachers, and they are hand in glove for profits. With a shortage of staff, invigilators threaten go on mass strikes if any action is taken. Conducting the exams, cancelling them on account of cheating and having re-exams are a loss of time and money for the government and this vicious cycle goes on. As the Nodal Education Officer of the district, address the following questions: (a) What are the ethical issues involved in the above case? (b) How will you resolve the issues in the given case? (c) What long-term strategy needs to be adopted to deal with the menace of cheating in various examinations?
Animesh Pradhan, AIR 2, 2023
In the words of Martin Luther King Jr., "intelligence plus character should be the true goal of education" But the sorry state of education due to cheating is testament to the failure of social values & democratic institutions to realise the true goal of education.
(a) Ethical issues involved
1. Productivity vs Morality - Nodal Education Officer (NEO) can jeopardise the smooth conduct of exam & waste resources if take action; but without any action, morality gets corroded.
2. Ends vs Means - Kant's categorical Imperative cannot be applied due to lack of universality & moral good in the 'means' if no action is taken.
3. Short term goal vs long term goal - Short term goal: Conduct of exam; prevent wastage of resources; smooth functioning of school - Long term goal: Fix the system with transparent regime; Merit should be celebrated; Ethical education & teachership
4. Align with team vs conscience If the officer takes action, the teacher community will dissociate from him, but at conscience he understanding the implication of such unethical act.
(b) Ways to Resolve the Issue
1. Incentivise teachers & conduct meetings with them - ensure to fight for teacher demands if they cooperate
2. Use of CCTV and other digital tools to ensure transparency & accountability
3. Rope in officer from other department to conduct & invigilate the exams if the school teachers do not cooperate
4. As a means of last resort, utilise civil society & media in highlighting the unethical behaviour of teachers and conduct the exams in ethical manner.
5. Seek help from higher management for more staff for conduct the exam in a transparent manner.
6. Meetings with children & parents to discuss various issues and grievances.
(c) Long-term strategy
Hence, in lines with SDG-5, Gandhiji's ideals are apt where he says "education is not only about literacy, but allround development of mind, body & spirit"