Rina and her friends from the college were working as interns with a company for the last few months. On completion of their internship, some of them, including Rina, have been offered full-time jobs in the company. Being a reputed company, she and her friends accepted the offer. Rina is enthusiastic about her new job and has even established good relationship with some of her company co-workers during her internship. However, during her tenure as an intern, Rina had begun to notice that one of the Vice-Presidents (VPs) of the company was giving her too much attention. He used to make an extra effort to stop by Rina's cubicle and chat, something he was not doing with any of the other interns. He had even tried to connect with Rina over social networking sites. Some of her co-interns also noticed this and began to make offhand comments to Rina about the extra attention being given by the VP. Now that she was has been hired for a full time position, she is fearful that she might have to work with this VP directly. While he has not done or said anything explicitly inappropriate, the extra attention and the fact that her co-workers noticed it, made her very uncomfortable and undermined her concentration at work. The company encourages an open and friendly atmosphere and when she was hired, it was communicated to her that she should always speak to her Manager whenever faced with any uncomfortable work related issues. However, she is concerned to speak about it officially, as the VP has not explicitly done anything wrong. In the given situation: (a) What dilemmas does Rina face? (b) What options does she have? Provide the merits and demerits of each. (c) Highlight the course of action she should adopt, along with justification for the same.
Animesh Pradhan, AIR 2, 2023
In Vishakha vs State of Rajasthan (1994), supreme court highlighted the need to create a safe & amicable workplace for women to improve safety & labour force partizipation of women.
(a) Dilemmas that Rina face
1. Personal insticts vs reality since the VP has not made any substantial wrong, verbally or by action, there is a dilemma if her uncomfort is a product of social & peer conditioning or a valid concern
2. Personal safety vs professional goals Taking any sort of action without any proof can hinder Rina's personal & professional growth (she can be assumed to be difficult to work with). But here personal safety is at stake as well.
3. To remain silent or take action - wheather to wait for substantive action by VP but that can jeopardise her wellbeing & safety.
4. Belief coworkers or not - because coworkers could be jealous because of Rina's association with VP and condition her to believe it as a matter of uncomfort.
(b) Options that Rina has
(i) stay silent & wait for any action
| Merit | Demerit | |---|---| | Professional growth | Personal safety at stake | | Association with VP can be useful for promotion professionally | Peers might find her opportunistic | | Better projects | Constant state of fear & anxiety |
(ii) Complain to the HR/authorities/manager
| Merit | Demerit | |---|---| | Her wellbeing & safety could be preserved | VP could be a gentleman & friendly person | | VP might be called out, similar experiences by fellow colleague will come out | Rina can have to go through tedious investigation | | Workplace becomes safer | would be assumed to be 'too sensitive' to work with | | Relation with peer improves | if found false, she could face repurcussions like suspension etc. |
(iii) Confront with VP amicably
| Merit | Demerit | |---|---| | All sorts of confusion get cleared | VP can have grudge against Rina | | VP gets warning & deterred if having any malicious intentions | Affect her personal & professional career | | Peer relations improve for Rina | VP, if had no intentions, will be very self cautious in expressing himself | | low involvement of authorities/manager | |
(iv) leave the company
| Merit | Demerit | |---|---| | safer workplace | Misses out good professional career | | low anxiety | scope of similar incidents elsewhere |
(c) Course of action that she should adopt, similar to solution (b)(ii)
Women continue to face situation similar to Rina, but with POSH Act, 2013 & formation of Internal Complaints Committee & 'SHEBox' for grievance, workplaces are becoming safer.