The principle of impartiality may conflict with the need for compassion towards marginalized communities. Discuss in the context of civil services in India.
Bhavika Chopra, AIR 25, 2025
Impartiality is the hallmark of a democratic society operating on principles upholding legal-rational authority.
Conflict between impartiality and compassion towards marginalised 1. Data based decision v/s special needs of marginalised (Eg: Tribal communities) 2. Discretion necessary for impartiality but room for compassion (Eg: Positive discrimination)
Civil servants are implementing the constitutional values on the ground, thus must have compassion: 1. Equality resulting from equity. Eg: Skill based upliftment for women 2. Justice as a result of correcting historical wrongs - compassion at play with PM-JANMAN 3. Specific needs met via push to education - Eg: scholarships etc. 4. Evaluation of policy effectiveness - mapping out vulnerable section impact. Eg: gender budgeting 5. Policy formulation for maximum good - upholding JS Mill's Utilitarianism and No harm principle. Eg: Development v/s displacement need, gig workers, women workers etc.
Thus, the impartiality characteristic of a bureaucracy must be balanced with a need for compassion.