What do you understand by environmental ethics? Examine the ethical concerns in 'phase-down versus phase out debate' in the use of coal by developing countries.
Bhavika Chopra, AIR 25, 2025
Environmental ethics deals with issues surrounding the natural environment and other factors. Eg: 1. Environment v/s development conservation 2. Deep sea mining v/s biodiversity conservation 3. Forest rights to indigenous people v/s developmental needs via forest use
Phase-down v/s phase out debate around coal 1. Developed countries seeking to phase-out fossil fuels; historically largest emitters across globe. 2. Developing countries yet to industrialise and lift people out of poverty. 3. Phase-down based on principle of common but differentiated responsibility. 4. Emissions exported to China via shifting manufacturing base for use of cheap labour, from USA, Europe etc.
Thus, given that just energy transitions must be the way ahead, developing countries must reduce high per-capita emissions and aid the transition from fossil fuel to green energy in developing nations via financial and technological assistance.