Topper Copies

In a metropolitan city of India, the law enforcement authorities decided to adopt facial recognition technology to improve their crime-fighting capabilities. They implemented a facial recognition system that integrated with existing surveillance cameras across the city, allowing real-time identification and tracking of individuals. The system was intended to assist in identifying known criminals, missing persons, and suspects in ongoing investigations. One evening, a woman reported a mugging incident where the perpetrator wore a hoodie, obscuring most of his face. The victim provided a vague description to the police, and based on that information, the authorities decided to use facial recognition technology to locate potential suspects. The system scanned through hours of surveillance footage from various locations near the crime scene. The facial recognition algorithm generated a list of potential matches, and one individual's image stood out as a close match to the description provided by the victim. The police considered this individual a prime suspect and proceeded with his arrest. Subsequently, it was discovered that the arrested person was innocent. Further investigation revealed that the facial recognition system had misidentified the innocent individual due to the limitations of the technology and the partial description provided by the victim. The police released the arrested individual; still his reputation got tarnished for life. He, along with his family, was evicted from their current place of residence. The psychological impact of the incident has been tremendous owing to which his job is also on the line. With reference to this case study, answer the following: (a) What are the issues involved in this case? (b) What measures can be taken to minimize the negative implications of adopting such technologies?

Animesh Pradhan, AIR 2, 2023

Modernisation of Police Scheme and Prakash Singh vs UoI stresses on the use of technology by police forces to instill capacity building, transparency, effectiveness & objectivity.

(a) Issues involved in the case

1. Breakdown of law & order where inspite of laws, robbing and mugging are prevalant in the society - 'erosion of ethics' in the society

2. Inadequacy of technology in crime profiling where it fails to deliver the accepted & correct results.

3. Innocent getting punished due to fault of technology & police, innocent individual & his family had to suffer and face perseacution.

4. Fault & Issues with Police to blindly believe on the algorithm results of the facial recognition technology without their own due diligence.

5. Prejudices in society - as seen in neighbours of the false accused who held grudges inspite of the accused be aquitted and with no punishment.

6. larger responsibility of law makers to build SOPs that uses both technology & human intervention in investigation.

(b) Measures to be taken to minimise the negative implications of adopting such technology

Various stakeholders

1. Police - 'SMART' Policing that is tech savvy but uses it as a supplement to their investigation & not as a replacement

2. Algorithm Builders of facial technology to be socially responsible, use more representative data, remove biases & prejudices. Ex RAISE - programme for social responsible use of AI.

3. Administration - creation of norms, best practices & SOPs to ensure minimal harm is done to the individual under investigation & build SOPs to judicious use of technology.

4. Technology transfere - International collaboration and academia support to enhance the accuracy & robustness of such technology.

5. Awareness & sensitisation among public to destigmatise about police and prevent 'moral policing' by society through appropriate campaigns.

Hence, advocated in Sadhna Haldar vs NCT, judiciary stresses on the ethical usage of facial recognition technology to make the criminal justice more responsible, yet empathetic.