Topper Copies

"Those who would give up essential liberty to purchase a little temporary safety, deserve neither liberty nor safety." In the context of this statement, bring out the ethical issues involved with creating a surveillance state for the sake of national security.

Bhavika Chopra, AIR 25, 2025

George Orwell's 1984 warns against the dangers of a surveillance state by illustrating the adverse impact of state policing and surveillance on personal and public lives of individuals.

Ethical issues with surveillance state 1. Risks creating an authoritarian state (Hannah Arendt - not instilling convictions, but destroying the ability to form any) 2. Creates self-censorship via a 'chilling effect'. (Foucault's panopticon) 3. Risks liberty - Article 21 via violating right to privacy. 4. Prevents full potential development of people - unable to question/debate. 5. Opens up avenues for a police state. Eg: Racial profiling 6. Risks becoming an absolutist state by crushing dissent (Dissent is the safety valve of democracy - CJI DY Chandrachud)

Balancing out national security and liberty 1. Adherence to procedure (as in Telegraph rules) 2. Non-bias in facial recognition AI technology (religion based profiling) 3. Maintaining sanctity of private sphere of individuals. 4. Upholding rule of law and constitutional supremacy.

Thus, both objectives require trade-offs but are not mutually exclusive for existence of a healthy society.