Rina and her friends from the college were working as interns with a company for the last few months. On completion of their internship, some of them, including Rina, have been offered full-time jobs in the company. Being a reputed company, she and her friends accepted the offer. Rina is enthusiastic about her new job and has even established good relationship with some of her company co-workers during her internship. However, during her tenure as an intern, Rina had begun to notice that one of the Vice-Presidents (VPs) of the company was giving her too much attention. He used to make an extra effort to stop by Rina's cubicle and chat, something he was not doing with any of the other interns. He had even tried to connect with Rina over social networking sites. Some of her co-interns also noticed this and began to make offhand comments to Rina about the extra attention being given by the VP. Now that she was has been hired for a full time position, she is fearful that she might have to work with this VP directly. While he has not done or said anything explicitly inappropriate, the extra attention and the fact that her co-workers noticed it, made her very uncomfortable and undermined her concentration at work. The company encourages an open and friendly atmosphere and when she was hired, it was communicated to her that she should always speak to her Manager whenever faced with any uncomfortable work related issues. However, she is concerned to speak about it officially, as the VP has not explicitly done anything wrong. In the given situation: (a) What dilemmas does Rina face? (b) What options does she have? Provide the merits and demerits of each. (c) Highlight the course of action she should adopt, along with justification for the same. (Answer in 250 words)
Bhavika Chopra, AIR 25, 2025
The aforementioned case study deals with a female employee getting unwanted attention from a senior colleague, that may question her capability to work as an intern transitioning to a full time employer.
Dilemmas Rina faces:
1. Career advancement and stability v/s harm to credibility 2. no official statement could be made if she faces no harassment. 3. Special attention to Rina v/s damage to her reputation among her friends.
Where Rina may not face any direct threat, the very fact that she feels uncomfortable provides her with the following options:
(1) Keep quiet and do nothing about it
| PROS | CONS | |---|---| | career stability and possible career advancement | questions on professional ability | | will transition to a full time employer with no hiccups | reputational damage among friends | | job security and harmonious work relations | feelings of discomfort | | | compromise on personal values of integrity and self-respect |
(2) make an official complaint
| PROS | CONS | |---|---| | will uphold self respect and personal values | will impact work relations with superiors | | can clear reputational damage | may be a rash decision | | | may threaten job security |
(3) Speak with manager un-officially and then take action
| PROS | CONS | |---|---| | does not make a rash decision | may spark concern in company | | upholds personal values | Rina could be reading too much into situation | | career is not threatened | | | takes advice from senior | |
(c) Course of action for Rina:
"... this above all, to thine own self be true" - Polonius in Hamlet by William Shakespeare
Thus, if Rina feels discomfort, she must address it via speaking to her manager:
| WHAT? | WHY? | |---|---| | 1. unofficially speak to manager | 1. prevents rash and hasty decision, upholds high emotional intelligence | | 2. no tolerance for special treatment | 2. showcases her integrity - only to be rewarded for ability, not for "pretty privilige" | | 3. take action based on advice, speak to VP directly about behaviour | 3. showcases moral courage, upholds organisational impartiality and maintains Rina's self respect. |
Thus, for cognitive consonance, Rina must address the situation to be at peace:
[diagram: three overlapping circles labelled action, thought and belief, converging on "RINA'S INTEGRITY"]