Topper Copies

Traditional forms of state-led accountability, also characterised as vertical and horizontal channels of accountability, are increasingly found to be inadequate, and a myriad of multi-stakeholder and bottom-up citizen directed approaches have come to the fore, to supplement or supplant them. Discuss with illustrations. (Answer in 150 words)

Bhavika Chopra, AIR 25, 2025

Traditional forms of state (HORIZONTAL) accountability rely on parliamentary checks on the executive, judicial checks on legislative and executive action. And (VERTICAL) state accountability measures such as elections, permanent executive responsible to elected executive and higher judicial checks on lower judiciary lead to inadequacy in accountability.

The alternatives:

1. Pressure groups in society: Women's pressure groups such as SEWA. 2. Use of methods of peaceful protest: such as Farm Laws Protest 3. Citizens' charter movement for public service delivery. 4. Right to information: to ensure executive accountability. 5. Right to Service Act: for government organisations performing prescribed role.

Thus, the bottom-up approaches that involve multiple stakeholders ensure accountability of the state as Voltaire might have imagined in his writings.