Examine the tension between the right to contest elections and the need to uphold electoral ethics under the Representation of the People Act. Should there be a lifetime ban on convicted criminals?
Bhavika Chopra, AIR 25, 2025
Under the RoPA, 1951, certain electoral offences disqualify a candidate from assemblies or the parliament.
Tension between right to contest elections with electoral ethics; need for latter:
1. Law making in legislatures - temples of democracy (discussion, deliberation, debate) 2. criminal antecedents may speak of low moral character of legislator 3. Large scale criminalisation of politics → 33% MPs with criminal charges in 17th Lok Sabha 4. Erosion of moral fabric of elections and democratic polity 5. Leads to strong-man politics - money and muscle power 6. Leads to erosion of public trust
However, a flip side exists:
1. Use of frivolous charges against opposition. Eg: Defamation case against Leader of opposition 2. Suppression of dissent in house 3. Arbitrary use of power to prevent electoral participation 4. Troubled relation with political targeting - from colonial times to Emergency era - Political prisoners a legacy issue
Thus, a lifetime ban on convicted criminals can be enforced for heinous crimes. Eg: Rape, sexual violence, Atrocities against SC/STs, terror charges etc.
Case against lifetime ban
1. Political weaponisation, UAPA misuse 2. may lead to chilling effect. Eg: Stan Swamy case, Umar Khalid
Thus, existing provisions must be used judiciously:
1. Declaration of criminal antecedents 2. Enforcing Lily Thomas judgment regarding section 8(4) 3. Use of powers by Election Commission 4. Trusting the judgment of voters
Thus, the electorate must be accorded the right to know for free and fair elections, and for a criminal free political space.