Topper Copies

The restrictions imposed under Article 293 of the Constitution on State borrowing powers, though constitutionally valid, may hinder fiscal autonomy of States and disrupt cooperative federalism. Discuss in the light of recent developments.

Bhavika Chopra, AIR 25, 2025

The recent dispute under Article 131 where Kerala has filed against the union government for restricting borrowing under Article 293 speaks to the states' limited fiscal autonomy.

Article 293: States can only borrow from market if the union government allows → if they do not owe debt to Union government, then no permission needed.

Limited fiscal autonomy of states:

1. more prevalent in southern states with low fertility rates (average of 1.9) thus have huge fiscal burdens 2. most grants tied to conditions. Eg: Centrally sponsored schemes 3. Erosion of state discretion - development needs unique across states 4. Limited pool of resources - cess and surcharges and customs not part of divisible pool 5. A-293 limits market borrowing 6. GST → Limited SGST discretion and eventual phasing out of compensation

Disruption of Cooperative Federalism

1. SR Bommai Judgement → States are not organs of Union government, independent units 2. Lack of input from states for discretion of funds 3. Violative of principle of subsidiarity → development needs not democratised via decisional autonomy

Thus, this limited fiscal autonomy leads to tangible fissures in the federal set up of the country.

Thus, cooperative federalism envisages devolution of funds, functions and functionaries - changing the way states earn and borrow can aid fiscal autonomy and cooperative federalism.