Topper Copies

The Reserve Bank of India's surplus transfers offer the government much-needed fiscal space, yet they are not without challenges. Critically examine the implications of the RBI's surplus transfers to the government. (Answer in 150 words)

Akansh Dhull, AIR 3, 2025

After Bimal Jalan committee's recommendation, in 2019 the RBI transferred ₹1,60,000 crore to Govt. Post that RBI is regularly transferring surplus.

Implications of RBI's transfer 1. Helps government in fiscal deficit target (4.5% of GDP in 2025-2026) 2. Source of non tax revenue -> no risk of crowding out of private funds (Ricardian Influence) 3. Mandate of RBI Act, 1935 4. RBI is 100% government owned body. Thus government is rightful to claim surplus 5. Ensures proper management of finances -> efficient utilisation and no wastage 6. Support to government's welfare programme 7. More funds available for capital expenditure -> long term infrastructure creation

Challenges of RBI's surplus transfer 1. Issue of conflict of interest 2. Violates independence of RBI as money supply controller 3. RBI may need funds for volatility management, controlling money supply 4. Challenges mandate of Monetary Policy Committee (Sec 4Z of the RBI Act, 1934)

Way Forward 1. Transfer by RBI after fulfilling its buffer requirement 2. Formula should be dynamically altered as per emerging scenario 3. No coercion of transfer, as it risks long term economic stability

RBI transfer should balance long term economic stability and short term fiscal situation of government.