Topper Copies

It is believed that a nation is an "imagined community" held together by common beliefs, history, political aspirations etc. In this context, discuss what the basis of India as a nation is. Also, bring out the threats to the concept of Indian nationhood. (Answer in 150 words)

Bhavika Chopra, AIR 25, 2025

India has long been an inclusive civilisation and continues to be so even as a modern nation state.

Basis of India as a nation

1. Rooted in ideals of Freedom struggle: non-violence, justice, equality and liberty with fraternity. 2. Constitutional morality: with one single citizenship - not as binary identities (linguistic, regional etc. but national) 3. Political Representation: that is reflective of common aspirations and is inclusive and open to all regardless of social background. 4. Accomodation of overlapping identities: Eg: a Punjabi muslim, a Southern state christian, a North Eastern state christian etc.

Threats to nation idea

1. Highlighting one identity over the other (Eg: Kuki and meitei tribes violence) as pointed out by Amartya Sen 2. Spread of fake news and media sensationalisation. 3. Caste-based fracture lines. 4. Communal identities that lead to violence (Eg: Nuh violent clashes) 5. Gendered identities and ostracisation Eg: LGBTQIA+ communities

Thus, India as a nation rests on the idea that it belongs to all who are part of it. Isolating anyone can lead to feelings of not belonging, thus harming the unity of the nation.