The Supreme Court, in a recent verdict, prescribed a time period for the Governor's assent to state legislative bills. What are the implications of this judgment for cooperative federalism and legislative accountability in India?
Bhavika Chopra, AIR 25, 2025
Under Article 200, the Governor could exercise the following options earlier:
1. withhold assent 2. give assent 3. refuse assent 4. with-hold for President
The supreme court judgment has brought about changes: (not to plug court powers)
1. Assent in 2 months or deemed passed 2. Refuse assent - if resent without changes then deemed passed 3. Presidential assent limit - one month 4. Writ of mandamus applies to President and Governor
Implications for cooperative federalism:
1. creation of legislative supremacy in a way - of state over governor 2. constitutional question of President's office under writ jurisdiction 3. Lack of discretion to governor - seen as an agent of union 4. Time limit to President - an apolitical office 5. Creates friction between State Assemblies and union government
Implications for legislative accountability:
1. Fast-tracking legislative processes 2. Increase in legislative productivity 3. may lead to better governance outcomes 4. may lead to hasty decisions 5. may subvert union authority over state governments 6. However, upholds legislative mandate:
Electoral → Legislature → Executive mandate Triple chain of accountability
Thus, with the Presidential referral under A.143, the dust is yet to settle on this issue.