Topper Copies

Copying is safe; innovation demands courage.

Bhavika Chopra, AIR 25, 2025

"Copying is safe; innovation demands courage."

The US led invasion of Iraq went awry in a matter of about four years in. Scholars of international relations often attribute this to a "crisis of leadership" in the USA. The people inherited mass wealth, stability and a well-oiled state apparatus. But good times breed complacency, and by extension a leadership which knows how to get things done - but does not ask why. Knows to answer all the right questions but does not know how to ask the right ones. It knows the direction in which it proceeds, but knows not the vision behind it or the reason.

Doing things as they had been done - "copying", was seen as safe and any deviation or innovation to deal with crisis was met with aversion - as usually is the case with those who possess the courage to innovate.

A manifestation of this is seen in bureaucracies worldwide, with India being no exception to it - a large state apparatus riddden with a strict adherence to rules - often copying those left behind by the colonial government that once ruled the subcontinent.

It is only recently that many colonial laws faced an overhaul - the Indian Penal Code, the Criminal Procedure Code and the Indian Evidence Act being replaced by the Bhartiya Nyaya Sanhita, Bhartiya Nagrik Suraksha Sanhita and Bhartiya Sakshya Adhiniyam. Not only do these laws seek to break the iron cage of rationality that had so far caged the Indian state, but also moves to innovation - in the form of restitutive justice. With provisions of community service, criminalising mob lynching and other new features, the legislations move away from copying to innovating.

This culture of innovation has long existed in Indian society - with innovations in the scientific sphere where Aryabhatta, Charak and Panini enhanced the understanding of astronomy, biology and grammar respectively. But it also existed in the cultural sphere, where societal mavericks of their time - Gautama Buddha and Mahavira gave to the masses a new and egalitarian way of thinking.

Buddhism and Jainism questioned the extant varna system and sought to innovate, rather than copy how life had been lived up until then. It can be said with conviction that these new ways of thinking had both spatial and temporal impacts. Buddhism spread across Asia - making its way to South East Asia, China and Ceylon.

Across time, Lord Buddha's innovative thinking still dictates India's approach at global fora. When our Prime minister stated that "India gave the world Budh, not Yudh", he highlighted the shift from war to dialogue in a conflict ridden world. Where the world is strife with conflict - ranging from the ongoing crisis in the middle East to the Russia-Ukraine war to tensions between Cambodia and Thailand,- copying the approach of countering violence with more violence feels safe. What it needs, though, is innovation in thinking and diplomacy.

However, it is not as if innovators have had public support. When Copernicus put forth the idea of a helio-centric universe, he was excommunicated from the Catholic church. Thinkers of the European Renaissance failed to copy the monarchical system's thinking - and in that courage for innovation ended up giving the world ideals of liberty, equality and fraternity. These also often form the basis of many modern constititions - but were accepted long ago; showing that though innovators are persecuted, their impact lasts for generations.

So was the case with the Wright Brothers, to whom we owe modern aircrafts; Thomas Edison, to whom we owe the lightbulb; Ada Lovelace, to whom we owe modern coding and computer languages and Einstein; to whom we owe a new understanding of reality.

These inventions needed courage to break paradigms that existed, needed critical thinking for moving away from an approach based on copying and a personal moral compass guiding their actions.

On the other side, no matter the intention, innovation left unchecked can often lead to deleterious impacts for society. Einsteins theory of relativity and his work was pivotal in the development of nuclear weapons in the Manhattan Project - an unintended consequence of innovation.

When James Watt invented the steam engine, it was done with the intention of making coal extraction easier in 17th century Britain. In no way could he have foreseen its modern impacts - an increase in standards of living, but also exploitation in sweatshops across Asia. A domino effect starting with mass production and industrialisation ultimately leading to colonialism and culminating in an exploited Bangladeshi woman working in a factory for wages far lower than the products she produces.

The repercussions of the first industrial revolution are only just making themselves evident - global imbalances and the north-South dichotomy; which brings one to think; what unintended consequences will the ongoing fourth industrial revolution have?

Recent advancements in artificial intelligence have made routine tasks easier - but also threatened job security among vulnerable sections. Advancements in gene technology such as CRISPR-Cas9 can now help edit out genetic diseases (such as down syndrome) from the human germline. But what impact does it have on a globally stratified society? What happens when only those with material resources access these advancements? Does humanity risk translating wealth inequality into genetic inequality?

Beyond this, human beings often forget that life imitates art. Unmindful of this, a company in the US has reconstructed the DNA pool of direwolves, which were once extinct. not only does it raise concerns that are ethical in nature (what do two wolves - pack animals in nature - do as a pair?), but also those around real, tangible threats.

Copying is safe - and innovation requires courage - but when does that innovation threaten safety? Both - that of the individual and the society. Though quite far from an apocalyptic AI take over (as in various scientific fiction movies) and far from a Jurrasic park coming to life, questions must be asked - whom is innovation serving? when is copying safe? and most importantly - how does one safeguard innovation in the best interests of society?

When benefits accrue to only the wealthy in society, the state plays an important role in dispersal of information. Be it the IPR regime, or vaccine development or artificial intelligence.

Research, too, must be available to the masses - a tangible step in the direction being the Indian governments' One Nation One Subscription, where research is available - not just for copying, but for building scientific temper; and using it as a stepping stone.

Innovation breeds further innovation - as the world adopts digital public infrastructure, it also radically changes how public services are administered. Innovations in India ranging from the direct benefit transfer to the aadhaar card system moved away from the safe, copying approach. This highlights how innovation must benefit society as a whole - not just those wealthy enough to be able to afford medical services and technology, often unfettered.

It is this unfettered access and changes that come along with it that must be handled with caution. For example, who dictates the rules for the AI training datasets? when there are no norms to copy, how does the state regulate new innovations?

Perhaps the answer lies in using caution and foresight - an impact analysis, often done in the form of a sandbox approach. Making mistakes and fixing them when no template to copy from exists - such as with AI innovation, gene technology and other frontier technologies.

This caution and foresight is possible when leaders ask the right questions - whom does an innovation benefit? When benefits are better distributed - such as vaccine IPR to global south countries; and when the courage to do things differently overpowers the need for being complicit.

As a new era is ushered in - with a global vacuum in able leadership - perhaps a culture built on millenia of civilisation and a penchant for questioning and innovation can guide the world. Perhaps this vacuum in leadership is where India finds its place on the global stage - not copying, but courageously innovating as the Vishwaguru.