Topper Copies

In matters of conscience, the law of the majority has no place.

Bhavika Chopra, AIR 25, 2025

"In matters of conscience, the law of the majority has no place."

"As the founding fathers signed the American declaration of independence with one hand, with the other they brandished a whip over their affrighted slaves," said by Martin Luther King Jr., speaks to the immorality of the Jim Crows laws and racial divide persistant in the USA in the 1960s. not only was this discrimination accepted by the majority, but was rather sanctioned by the law. Where on the one hand, the American Revolution gave the world the powerful statement of "we take these truths to be self evident that all men are born equal"; it was not until President Johnson signed the Civil Rights Act in 1968 that it became a legal reality.

The long struggle against racial discrimination entrenched in law began with the single act of Rosa Parks refusing to give up her seat for a white man. An act of conscience, committed against the law of the majority.

It is widely known that Mahatma Gandhi, too, spoke of a higher court of law - his conscience, when being tried by the colonial government. It is this dichotomy between law and conscience that often leads to unsuspected, small acts of kindness becoming excellent examples of bowing before this higher court.

Nowhere is this more evident, in the movie Schindlers List, where a German National saves multiple Jewish lives during the holocaust.

What people remember are the horrors of the holocaust - but what people forget is that the Nazi government that sanctioned the deaths was legally elected. The concentration camps worked based on rules and an unquestioning obedience to hierarchy. Hitlers government rose to power on a legal basis - elected by the people. One would wash them all blame on the premise that they refused direct part in the atrocities, but in not listening to their conscience and looking the other way, perhaps most are complicit.

As war rages in Gaza and the world looks the other way, the cries of "never again" are not forgotten, but dulled by the din of moral sanction most powers provide for eradication of Hamas from the region by use of violent means.

Closer to home, this violence impacts areas of insurgency, such as the north-East India and Jammu and Kashmir. Under the Armed Forces Special Protection Act, Indian personnel commit atrocities; often undocumented. not only does this legal sanction violate the rights of the people impacted but hits at the very heart of India's constititional ethos. A legacy of acceptance of minorities and integration into Indian culture has given India the civilisational character that defines its' legal landscape.

Despite being an electoral democracy that works on the formation of a majority in the lower house, India's parliament provides for affirmative action in the form of reservations for scheduled castes, scheduled tribes and now, even for women.

Despite this, marital rape ceases from being a crime in India even though it violates any sane persons' conscientious thoughts. The law of the majority dictates that de facto - the wife's body does remain the husbands' property.

Many such instances exist globally as well. Upuntil recently, women in Saudi Arabia could not drive. Until the 1990s, unmarried but pregnant women in Ireland were locked up in 'magdalene rooms'. Upuntil 1991, it was forgiven if a man murdered his spouse for infidelity in Brazil - it was seen as a crime of passion. It was in 1988 that women in switzerland did not require their husbands permission to work and in 1974 in the USA that women were allowed to finally access credit card facilities.

The law of the majority not only suppresses rights, but leaves behind a legacy of generational trauma - still visible in Dalit households in India and African American households in the USA.

This not only reflects in poor learning outcomes, but also in lower earning profiles among these demographics.

A famous Latin phrase reads, "Lex mulla, lex nulla" - which translates into - a bad law is no law. Which perhaps begs the question - what makes a law just and good?

Perhaps the Napoleanic code provides an answer - where a law is made by the people it intends to govern; two - it is short and fits in a pocket and three, is simple enough to be understood by the common man.

Several laws across history have not lived up to this code. The American Revolution took place because the law passed by British Parliament sought to tax Americans without representation. The colonial government in India, which often upheld rule by law and not rule 'of' law - meant to uphold justice.

Recently, the 'One Big Beautiful Bill' passed by the Trump administration is criticised for being too complex to be understood even by the Congressmen voting on it - making it complex and far removed from the people.

It is often forgotten that modern lawmakers and laws derive their power from the people - and must uphold moral conscience that resonates with them. Power rests, where people believe it rests - and a lack of belief in law often leads to extra-constitutional means when people cease to believe in it.

During the farmers' protests of 2020 against the farm laws, the farmers believed they were upholding higher morals that adhered to conscience, but were infact bringing to light a disconnectedness between the law of the majority and the people it would most impact - the vulnerable small farmers. For a harmonic society, the avenues of power must be paved with the values of conscience.

This conscience is the inner voice which guides all human beings in decision making - some choose to follow it, while some do not. Plato gives the example of a slippery slope - where one embarks on a downward journey as values are ignored and the internal conscience quietened for the external noise of society's norms.

These social norms existed worldwide in the form of whistle-blowers being called 'rats', 'snitches', 'snakes' and other vile terms before a US lawyer in the 1970s coined this term. The whistleblowers act on their conscience and blow the whistle - as a referee would, during foul play. Ranging from Erin Bronkovich in the US, to Satyendranath Dube in India and Cassandra in Greek mythology, not only are they socially ostracised but often face terrible consequences for standing up against the law of the majority.

Any change envisioned against unlawful acts (- not in the legal sphere - but unlawful in the court of morality) is met with resistance. Be it Raja Ram Mohun Roy's campaign against Sati - morally questionable but legally sanctioned. Or Iswar Chandra Vidyasagar's efforts for widow remarriage - not socially acceptable in early Hindu society.

This resistance is testament to the fact that social change takes place via voicing ones' beliefs of conscience. Audre Lorde famously said "You will not win anything by being silent".

It is this very silence, born out of moral discomfort and raised in a cradle of apathy that gives way to the law being a tool to oppress minorities.

Recently, the Bombay High Court refused the right to protest to a group speaking up against the atrocities in Gaza. The question remains - is it not a matter of conscience to speak for those who cannot speak for themselves? How does a court entrusted with guarding constitutional values turn a blind eye to the morals that form its' building blocks?

A constitution rooted in protection of minority rights and social justice - by way of protection to religious and cultural minorities and protection and upliftment of backward sections - is bound to give rise to an enlightened citizenry.

Thus, fending and speaking up for ones' conscience becomes a moral imperative - especially as war rages on in Gaza. The world must grapple with larger questions as well - what is the legacy that will be left behind? One that mirrors racial segregation on the global stage, or one that builds a just world - where the world is one family.

For the law of the majority to be questioned and replaced - the principle of 'vasudhaiva kutumbakam' must be internalised. Where law accomodates and allows for flourishing of minorities and dissenters, where conscience doesnot bow to majoritarian thinking and ultimately, where following the law and following ones' conscience are not mutually exclusive acts.