Topper Copies

Wealthy CEOs and founders of successful businesses around the world are increasingly pledging to give away their wealth in philanthropy. Do you think that such a move is sufficient enough to bring about a positive change in the society? Critically examine.

Animesh Pradhan, AIR 2, 2023

'Be the change you want to see in the World', various CEOs who believe in ethical corp capitalism & income equality are showing the way including Bill Gates, Azim Premji, Ratan Tata etc.

Positive Outcomes - Helpful in wealth redistribution as per Article 39(b) of DPSP & SDG-10 - Inspires people to pursue philanthrophy at various levels - Discourages material growth & materialistic attitudes - 'Maxim of Reciprocity' works where one belief that since she has got better because of others, it is her responsibility to pay back - Ethical capitalism gets manifested

But this is not sufficient in achieving a positive change

Insufficient for positive change - Proportion of philanthrophy is minuscule compared to wealth generated - Accused of 'greenwashing' or mere symbolic in nature - Reaffirms the belief that only rich can do philanthrophy - Used as a crony capitalistic move to create false brand image - lack of monitoring of such funds & their effectiveness - Core issues of discrimination, parity, prejudices still remain.

Even though Kant's Categorical Imperative appreciates philanthrophy, one must be careful about its outcomes & consiquences.