Topper Copies

Analyze the ideological differences and similarities between the revolutionary movement (1920-1930s) and the Gandhian non-violent struggle. How did these two ideologies influence each other?

Divyank Gupta, AIR 21, 2024

Indian Independence Movement was influenced by various ideologies like Gandhian, revolutionary, socialist, labour class which led to different form of struggles for Independence.

Ideological differences

| Revolutionary Movement | Gandhian Non-Violent Struggles | |---|---| | 1. Believed in use of force to get rid of Britishers - eg Surya Sen | 1. Believe in Ahimsa and Satyagraha | | 2. Believed in individual heroic action - eg Bhagat Singh killed Saunders | 2. Believed in mass movement - eg CDM | | 3. Believed that revolution could awaken the masses | 3. Believed that changing the heart is the most important factor | | 4. Were inspired from Irish and Russian revolutionaries | 4. Influenced from John Ruskin - Unto the last book and Indian values | | 5. They wanted to create fear among Britishers | 5. Wanted to ensure that Britishers themselves devolve power |

Similarities between two

1. Wanted an end to the British rule 2. Activity supported the method of each other - eg Bhagat Singh took part in NCM 3. Both had wide mass appeal among people 4. Both brought reform in administration - eg Trade disputes Act (1926) and forming of Nehru Report

Influence of revolutionaries on Gandhian movement

1. Gandhian movement often came under pressure to act quickly - eg CDM started just under 2 years 2. Gandhiji gave a call for do or die in Quit Indian Movement 3. Gandhiji said that violence is better than cowardice, and gave way to Gandhian movement of peaceful struggle

Thus both played very important role in freedom struggle.