Case Study: A smart city project is underway, and you have been appointed Head of Procurement. Before this assignment, you held a similar role in a major public sector undertaking (PSU), where you earned a reputation for your tender drafting and vendor management skills. Given the smart city project's scale and significant procurement requirements, you seemed the perfect fit to lead the procurement section. A month ago, your section invited tenders for building supplies. Among the applicants was Mr. Sharma, a supplier you knew from your previous role at the PSU. Mr. Sharma lived in your neighbourhood, and your spouses were friends. Despite this personal connection, you have always maintained strict professional boundaries. Upon scrutinising all the tenders, your section found Mr. Sharma's terms the most competitive, so the tender was awarded to him. However, once the decision was made public, another vendor, Mr Patel, accused you of colluding with Mr Sharma due to your previous relationship. Mr. Patel filed a formal complaint with the Department Seniors, providing evidence of your prior association with Mr. Sharma. As a result, an enquiry was initiated, and you were placed on compulsory leave pending its outcome. This situation left you questioning where you might have gone wrong despite your efforts to maintain professionalism. 1. Do you think the above case involves a conflict of interest or there are more issues? Explain 2. Keeping the above case in perspective, discuss the relevance of impartiality and non-partisanship as professional value. 3. In hindsight, how do you think you could have avoided the above unpleasant situation.
Divyank Gupta, AIR 21, 2024
The given case study highlights the issue of punishment even when a person is right.
There is a conflict of interest a. As I had a relation with Mr Sharma, still my section was involved b. I could have avoided the oversight of this case
However, there are more issues - a. Baseless accusation by Mr Patel, on the process and on me b. Not addressing potential conflict of interest c. Lack of transparency in the bidding process
Relevance of impartiality and non-partisanship as a professional value
For the individual a. Ensures moral uprightness in conduct b. Reduces complexity in dealing with conflict of interest c. Brings peace of mind d. Provides an opportunity to lead by example eg Julio Ribeiro
For the organisation a. Promotes probity in administration b. Better service delivery c. Better decision making d. Addresses nepotism and upholds the constitution
For the citizen a. Trust building in the institution b. Active engagement of the citizen c. In line with Plato's - the State is the individual writ large
This situation could have been avoided by a. Looking at potential conflict of interest b. Telling the organisation about it beforehand eg judges' recusal c. Promoting transparency and citizen's engagement eg Maharashtra's policy of anyone checking its files d. Devolution of power to a committee, rather than discretion
Despite this, I will not lose faith in moral uprightness, as Confucius said, "Virtue is not left to be alone; those who possess it are bound to have neighbours."