Case Study: It was Assembly election times, and you were deputed to a constituency on election duty where one of your responsibilities was to monitor candidates' campaign expenses and supervise the campaigns' videography. As you take charge and start working, you realise the challenge you have got into. Two of the candidates had a criminal background, and the whole contest was more or less between these two only. As the campaigns picked pace, you noticed that both the candidates indulged in inciting the voters on caste and religious grounds. Further, they were doling out monetary inducements in blatant violation of the election code of conduct. You had all of it on record, thanks to your videographer. You decided to warn them before taking any strict action, so you called them and confronted them with the evidence. Much to your relief, they quietly accepted the mistake and promised to comply with the codes. Two days after the meeting, you get the news that one of your videographers was severely beaten by the goons of one of the candidates. And the beating of the videographer was meant as a warning to you. Further, the same evening you get a call threatening you with dire consequences if you interfere with the campaigns. You realise that your decisions are proving to be dangerous for the people working with you. You didn't feel good about endangering the safety of your staff. 1. What are the issues involved in the above case? 2. Is it ethically justified to be devoted to duty at the cost of the personal safety of the staff? Discuss. 3. How will you go about doing your election duties without compromising the safety of your staff? Explain.
Divyank Gupta, AIR 21, 2024
The case study talks about the money and muscle power present at election time, which hurt the fair electoral process.
My priorities, in rising order: ensure election duties are done the right way, safety of staff, and my own safety.
Issues involved in the case
| Stakeholders | Issues | |---|---| | The 2 candidates | Promoting hatred among people; end over means; hurting the fabric of democracy | | Me and my staff | To conduct the election at such times |
Is it ethically justified to be devoted to duty at the cost of staff's safety - Duty calls for sacrifice eg Satyendra Dubey - Duty leads to upholding of the Constitution - Every person, before entering the service, takes a pledge to serve till the last breath
Yet, there are some further issues of personal safety, taking care of female staff and their safety, and ensuring trust and safety to people who come to vote.
1. Wrong example to lead, when staff doesn't feel safe 2. Locke's natural and inalienable rights come at the top 3. It's my duty to ensure that no staff is hurt
My course of action a. Ask for more protection in the form of police and CRPF personnel b. Live telegraphy shown, so as to deter any action c. Ensuring strict guidelines on where staff members can and can't go, so as to address any threat d. Alerting the DM about a possible situation scenario e. Trust building among people, and promoting timely action f. Further, courage is contagious. My courage to stand up to the threats would help in deterring any threat to safety
It is during these times that courage of conviction is checked and a person's true character is revealed. I would, therefore, take inspiration from T N Seshan, who stood up to politicians during tough times.