Case Study: You are the Compliance Officer at GreenTech Industries, a company that manufactures eco-friendly products and believes in making positive environmental impacts. Your primary responsibility is to ensure that the company adheres to environmental laws and ethical standards. The Company recently developed a new product that promises significant ecological benefits but involves a manufacturing process that produces hazardous waste. During an internal audit, you discover that the hazardous waste from the new product's manufacturing process is being disposed of in a manner that technically meets legal standards but raises serious ethical concerns. While compliant with current laws, the disposal method poses potential risks to a local community's health and the environment in the long term. Legally, GreenTech Industries is not violating any regulations. However, ethically, you are aware that continued use of this method could significantly harm the local community and ecosystem. You were left wondering, on the one hand, the Company was legally correct, but on the other, it was hypocritical about its avowed values of positively impacting the environment. 1. What are the ethical issues and dilemmas that confronts you in the above case? 2. Discuss the available options along with its merits and demerits. 3. What will be your chosen course of action? Why
Divyank Gupta, AIR 21, 2024
The given case study highlights the issue that just being procedurally right is not enough; there should be ethically right too.
Ethical issues and dilemma 1. To follow my duty as an employee, or as a member of the larger community 2. Legality vs ethical right 3. Hypocrisy of Green Tech Company 4. Green Tech Company violating Kant's categorical imperative and Locke's natural and inalienable rights 5. Violation of the right to life under Article 21A of the Constitution 6. Violation of UN Human Rights, for a healthy living, for the community 7. Violation of the Sustainable Development Goal - SDG-3
Options available to me
| Option | Merit | Demerit | |---|---|---| | Ignore the issue, as the company is legally right | There will be no issue with the company; I have done my job | Against Kant's categorical imperative; hurt to the larger community; against the veil of ignorance (Rawls) | | Leak the information to the media and expose GreenTech | I did an ethical job; people's right to life upheld | Threat to my job; the company can find a different way to do such a thing; no real solution | | Make GreenTech aware about their CSR activities and the impact they could face if it gets leaked | Appeals to the heart of the company; might change the course of the future; no threat to my job | They might not accept it; action against me |
My chosen course of action
| Course of action | Justification | |---|---| | Meet with the Board of Governors and make them aware | Follow persuasion by appealing to the heart | | Inform them about past precedents like this eg Volkswagen's imposed fine of $33 Bn | Follow the social influence of talking about the fine | | Make them aware of their ethical duties | Talks about Kant's deontology and their CSR responsibilities | | If they agree, then follow their lead | Bertrand Russell said that in law, a man is guilty if he violates the legality, but in ethics, he is guilty if he violates the conscience | | Otherwise, become a whistleblower and leak this to stop it | It would promote justice, fairness and sustainability | | It would protect the lives of many people and their generation | |
Martin Luther King said that it is the silence of the good which lets evil triumph, and therefore, I would follow this course of action.