A. Explain the difference between conflict among interests and conflict among various sources of authority. Illustrate with relevant examples. B. The domain of governance is ridden with uncertainties, ambiguities and paradoxes and this can at times lead to timidity and withdrawal among public administrators. Discuss the relevance of inner courage for overcoming and coping with ambiguities.
Divyank Gupta, AIR 21, 2024
A. Conflict among interests vs conflict among sources of authority There are various types of conflict which exist in a person's life.
Conflict among interest 1. This is a conflict among different values and responsibilities of a person 2. This leads to an ethical dilemma 3. This can be avoided by disclosing it to people 4. This can lead to inner turmoil 5. Not following it lightly can lead to a crisis of conscience 6. There is also the issue of sabotaging personal life due to this
Conflict among various sources of authority 1. It is a conflict between different authorities, like institutions 2. This leads to a dilemma over which authority to follow 3. This can be addressed by properly adhering to rules 4. This leads to an impact on the administration 5. Not following this leads to punishment by authorities 6. This can sabotage the professional life
Thus they can be solved by - sticking to the rules and procedure - avoiding discretionary decisions - taking help from seniors - making seniors aware from the start
B. Inner courage and governance Stoics say that one should not go expecting Plato's Republic, as the administration and governance in real life is filled with uncertainties and ambiguities.
This leads to timidity and withdrawal 1. Public administrators just try to stick to rules and procedure 2. Some try to misuse power and lead to corruption eg IAS Pooja Singhal 3. This leads to procedural democracy rather than substantive democracy
Inner courage could help in overcoming this 1. Courage helps in facing challenges eg Kannan Gopinath during the Kerala floods 2. Courage motivates one to find a solution eg Armstrong Pame built a road through crowd funding 3. Courage helps in the courage of conviction eg IAS B Chandrakala against ministers 4. Courage motivates one to go an extra mile 5. It helps in establishing restorative justice 6. It promotes quality public service and, thereby, utilitarianism
Other measures - timely modifying the rules to reduce ambiguities - overlooking bonafide mistakes - reward and recognition to such people
This can ensure what Rabindranath Tagore said, that "I acted, and behold - service became joy."