A. "It is wrong to assume that ethical decisions are, can or should be purely rational and principled. Human feelings are an inseparable part of our ethical life." In what way do feelings impact our ethical decisions? Illustrate with examples. B. What do you understand by ethics management? Can public officials manage ethics in the work place in a manner similar to managing budgets, policies and people? Do you think adopting codes of ethics and conduct is sufficient enough for managing ethics in the workplace or something more is needed? Discuss.
Divyank Gupta, AIR 21, 2024
A. How feelings impact ethical decisions Darwin said that Man is a social animal who is very much driven by emotions and feelings.
Feelings impact our ethical decisions 1. Feelings towards our family members lead us to take an unethical path eg Dhritrashtra overlooked Duryodhana's mistakes. 2. Feeling for self interest overshadows integrity and moral rightedness eg IAS Puja Khedkar case. 3. Feelings for Nation might lead one to follow path of violence eg Bhagat Singh. 4. Feelings for Name, fame may make one unethical.
However, feelings can also do good things 1. Feeling can push one to do good eg Kailash Satyarthi said that all his actions were driven by anger. 2. Feelings of compassion promote right action eg Mother Teresa 3. Feeling of love and peace promote harmony eg Nelson Mandela 4. Feelings of serving the country promote right policies eg SBM by Parameshwar Iyer. 5. Feeling of more happiness leads to utilitarianism in policy making
Therefore right feelings can be promoted by - promoting value education since childhood eg CVC value education kit - inspiration from role model - attaching ourselves with higher purpose in life
Man is a social animal, but by correct upbringing and right path, he can move into a path where he can use his feelings for correct reasons.
B. Ethics management Ethics refers to a set of principles imposed by society on itself to guide moral conduct eg discipline in Japan's society.
Ethical Management It refers to managing the various ethics like utilitarian, deontology, for taking the right action eg in a pluralistic society, choosing between minority concerns and majority interests can become an issue. This requires ethics management.
Public officials can manage ethics in the workplace 1. There exists a code of conduct rules to guide public servants 2. All religions, which guide people, emphasize moral goodness. 3. Public officials have emotions of compassion, empathy eg Smita Sabharwal - Fund Your City project
Is code of conduct sufficient for managing ethics 1. It provides strict rules to follow in every situation. 2. Not following those rules is punished. 3. Consistency in rules brings predictability in conduct.
However, code of ethics and conduct have limitations 1. Code of ethics not formed in India. 2. Ethics can take various forms eg ethical egoism, ethical altruism. 3. Conduct rules can't be used in every situation.
Way forward - basic human goodness to act rightly - keeping interest of the weak in mind (Gandhi - Talisman) - role model inspiration
Einstein said that if people are right, no rules are required, and if they are wrong, they will find ways around those rules.