Topper Copies

Indo-Pacific region in recent times has emerged as a zone of diverging interests and priorities. Discuss. Do you think the Global Security Initiative will supersede QUAD in the region?

Prajnanandan Giri, AIR 24, 2023

Indo-pacific region has emerged as focus of global geo-politics due to its importance as major trade route (60% energy trade) as well as presence of major powers in the region.

Indo-pacific: Zone of diverging interest and priorities 1. China - Its interest lies with hegemony over Indo-pacific. (eg) South China Sea - Nine dash line claim, control over Taiwan - Maritime Silk route over Indo-pacific - Defence infra/Bases along choke points like Djibouti 2. India - Interest to become Net-security provider over Indian ocean - To prevent Chinese hegemony - Advance trade interest 3. USA - Sees China's rise as threat to its traditional power - Want to secure semi-conductor supply chain - overall influence on Indo-pacific 4. ASEAN - Wants a ASEAN-centric Indo-pacific - To combat China's claim over South China Sea

All these diverging interests have led to multiple groupings, militarisation etc over Indo-pacific.

Global Security Initiative vs QUAD - Global Security Initiative - By China - QUAD - By USA-India-Japan-Australia

Positives of GSI over QUAD - Potential to use economic might - Control over island countries through debt trap - Tries to bring NATO like grouping - support of Pakistan, Turkey, Iran etc

Cannot supersede QUAD - QUAD's strength -> USA's military, India's strategic position, Japan's technology - QUAD is a group of mature democracy -> goes beyond military ties - QUAD's objective is more liberal and in the interest of rule-based order

Therefore, QUAD need to focus on forming QUAD+ with similar minded nations of Indo-pacific to tackle the GSI of China.