S.R. Bommai v. Union of India signified a paradigm shift in the judicial interpretation of the union's authority to assume control of a state's administration. In this context discuss the significance and impact of the judgement on cementing the federal structure.
Prajnanandan Giri, AIR 24, 2023
In SR Bommai vs Union of India case of 1992-93, Supreme Court held that Article 356 on President's rule provision should not be misused to topple opposition-ruled state government.
Judicial Interpretation's significance 1. Brought the President's decision under Judicial Review. 2. On malafide intention, the state assembly to be restored. 3. President's rule should only be implemented, when there is a constitutional crisis and not on the ground of maladministration or corruption 4. The primary effort of Governor should be to find alternatives like coalition governments, if ruling party loses majority or in case of hung assembly. 5. It tried to interpret Governor's discretion in a narrow manner.
Impact of the Judgement 1. It reduced the implementation instances of Art 356 unlike the era of 1970s. 2. Ensured stability in state administration 3. Created restraint on the side of Governor and Central Government 4. Provided much needed autonomy to the state Government 5. Judicial Review of President's rule led to protection of states' rights later-on. (eg) Supreme Court reinstated Uttarakhand, Arunachal Assembly through such provision. 6. SR Bommai case - also declared Federalism as a basic structure -> Restricted Parliament towards any unilateral changes in these provisions.
Overall, SR Bommai Judgement was a watershed moment, that became basis of future judgements on Federal structure like Nebam Rabia Judgement. In this way, it strengthened India's federal structure as 'Union of States'.