Fundamental rights are not gifts, bestowed upon by the state rather an individual possesses them independently of the state. In this context discuss the desirability of reasonable restrictions on various fundamental rights.
Prajnanandan Giri, AIR 24, 2023
Fundamental rights are provided by constituent assembly to the citizens under Part III of the constitution, as protection against tyranny of the state and as few basic human rights.
FRs - Not Gifts rather individual possesses 1. Fundamental Rights are enforceable by court of law. 2. Helps in achieving constitutional objectives of liberty and equality 3. Also provides opportunity to individual for holistic development 4. They can not be taken away without procedure established by law. (Article 21)
However, there are several reasonable restrictions ->
Desirability of reasonable restrictions 1. FRs are not sacrosanct or absolute. They can be taken away in specific situations. 2. To uphold public order, morality and health (eg) Restriction on Article 25 -> Closure of temples, Mosques by Government in COVID-19 3. To protect national unity and sovereignty (eg) Sedition Laws as reasonable restriction on Freedom of speech (Kedarnath Singh case) 4. To protect the fundamental rights of other people or public at large. (eg) Restrictions like Defamation provisions, against Hate speech etc. (section 153A, 153B, 296A of IPC) 5. To protect and uphold the Law and order situation or Lives/livelihoods of public (eg) section 144 (CrPC), Ban on internet etc. (Anuradha Bhasin case)
However, the challenges are the misinterpretation of the word 'reasonable', that led to despotic tendency in executive. For example: 1. Sedition laws - <3% conviction rate 2. Unlimited internet ban - (eg) Manipur, Kashmir 3. Many defamation cases 4. Ban on voices of media - IT rules 2021
Therefore, as per SC's decisions over various cases, the reasonable restrictions should not violate the 'test of proportionality' and there should be minimum use of such restrictions in exceptional cases.