Topper Copies

Critics assert that limitless judicial authority rests on the structural ambiguity of the basic structure doctrine. Has the elastic nature of the basic structure doctrine made the judiciary more powerful than the executive?

Prajnanandan Giri, AIR 24, 2023

Basic structure Doctrine was given by Supreme Court in Kesavananda Bharati case in 1973. The doctrine says that Parliament can amend any part of constitution, but can not alter its basic structure.

Structural ambiguity of the doctrine 1. No written form of basic structures 2. Extra-constitutional interpretation 3. Provides discretion to judges 4. Asymmetric power structure -> towards Judicial Supremacy 5. Brings subjectivity in application of the doctrine.

Therefore, to some extent the doctrine made judiciary more powerful than executive ->

For example 1. It has led to Judicial Activism - with signs of supremacy of judiciary. (eg) NJAC case - SC declared the 99th amendment as unconstitutional, as Independence of Judiciary as basic structure. 2. Prevented steps by executive to advance Land reforms without interference (eg) IR Coelho case - 9th schedule was made under Judicial Review - as a basic structure. 3. Prevents any unilateral action by executive against states (eg) SR Bommai case - Federalism was declared as Basic structure 4. Other such basic structures are - Secularism, Parliamentary System, Free & Fair elections.

Positive aspects of basic structure 1. Prevented despotic tendencies of executive & legislative. (eg) 39th constitutional amendment Act to provide immunity from Judicial Review. 2. Created separation of power with effective checks and balances. 3. Protected constitutional morality and constitutionalism.

However, looking at the elastic nature of Basic Structure doctrine, there needs to be codification of the same to prevent discretionary interpretation by judges.

Overall, Basic Structure doctrine has created a system of effective checks and balances by providing slight advantage to Judiciary over executive.