How has the Anti-Defection law impacted the relationship between political parties and individual legislators in India? In light of the recent incidents also discuss the unintended consequences it has on the functioning of democracy in India.
Prajnanandan Giri, AIR 24, 2023
52nd Amendment Act of 1985 added 10th schedule into the constitution, which is known as Anti-defection Laws.
Anti-defection Law (ADL) 1. Disqualifies a MP/MLA if one resigns from political party or acts against the whip of the party. 2. Prevents independent member to join any political party. 3. Allows nominated member to join any political party within 6 months.
How ADL impacted relationship of political parties and legislators 1. Prevented horse trading to some extent by enforcing loyality to one's party 2. Reduced the significance of individual with respect to overarching party in debates & discussions 3. However, it treats nominated & independent members differently on defection. 4. Made speaker's role crucial to decide on disqualifications.
Recent Incidents 1. Use of two-third merger provision (eg) Shiv Sena issue in Maharashtra 2. Large scale disqualifications (eg) Madhya Pradesh assembly 3. Misuse of provisions to break ruling coalition governments.
Unintented consequences it has on functioning of democracy 1. Provides opportunity for corruption - use of money power to break smaller party. 2. Removes differentiation between 'dissent' and 'defect' -> reduced quality of debates in legislative assemblies. 3. Makes speakers' role crucial - but due to loyality towards own party, it has created partiality & partisan decision making. 4. Makes Election Commission a non-stakeholder in the process 5. Increased appeal cases against speaker in Courts.
Way forward 1. Decision on disqualification should be taken by President/Governor with binding advice of ECI -> (Dinesh Goswami committee) 2. Speaker needs to decide within fixed time period (Keisham Singh case) 3. Judicial review of decision as per Kihoto Holohan case
To ensure ADL to achieve its real objective of democratic functioning of legislatives, adequate reforms are need of the hour.