Present demonstrates the lessons of history, albeit the hard way.
Divyank Gupta, AIR 21, 2024
Present demonstrates the lessons of history, albeit the hard way
BHISMA: Why are you after this war, Krishna? You are a symbol of Peace. How can you promote war?
Krishna: Because there is no other way to establish dharma.
BHISHMA: But this war will cost lives of thousands
Krishna: Sometimes mankind has to learn things in a hard way so that the lesson would persist for millennials.
The above conversation is between Bhisma and Lord Krishna from Mahabharata just before their was going to be formal declaration of war. The conversation shows how human learn and respect something for which they have paid a big price in the past.
In this essay, we will see how present is shaped by lessons of history, Further we will see why these lessons come by a hard method. We will also see why then people forget these lessons and what happens in that case. Further, we will see what can be done to ensure that mankind doesn't forget the lessons of the past.
Present = Lessons From History
There is an ancient saying that if you want to understand the present, you should look for the past. It is because, the present is shaped by past. This could be seen in various aspects, be it social, economical or political.
Socially, if we see the concept of Caste in India is coming down. Now, we witness inter-caste marriages in India, there is no more prevalence of Jajmani System. This is the result of all the efforts made by various reformers like Jyotibha phulle, BR Ambedkar, Jagjeevan Ram etc. Their continuous efforts shaped the better conditions of lower caste people in present.
Economically, we can see the growth of India being one of the highest among the major economies due to continuous reforms which India took in the past. These reforms included privatisation to being more role of private sector in development, development of infrastructure through projects like Bharatmala, Sagarmala, etc.
Moving to Political aspect, we witness the linguistic reorganisation of states in India. It is the result of continuous struggle and demand by southern states in the past which led to States Reorganisation Act of 1956.
But what is common among the examples above. Well one thing is that they have been shaped by past but other thing is that they have not come in easy way. They have come after hard steps and big price paid by people in the past. This brings us to next part.
Present = Lesson Learnt in Hard Way
Why is Present shaped by past in Hard way? Well, it is because people know the cost that they have paid in the past for it and that is why they respect it. The well known example is why Congress didn't split in 1916 when there were internal clashes among Muslim league and Hindu Mahasabha was because they had seen the impact of Swat split in 1907. It was because of hard lesson of Swat split that congress unified during Khilafat and non-cooperation Movement.
Another reason why Present is lesson from past but in hard way is that not every time people want to do the hard things. For example, the linguistic reorganisation came after massive protest in south after death of activist Pottiralu Sriram. But not every time people can come up with sacrifices like this. As a result, Even when there are North-South divide in India over allotment of financial resources or language issue, we don't witness demand of secession like we used to during times of independence.
Moreover, when people pay a price for something, they don't want to go it waste and that is why they bring continuous reform in it. The examples of 1976 emergency is a case in point. Emergency which is called the darkest phase of democracy forced the successive governments to ensure effective checks and balance like - reducing the scope of emergency from internal disturbance to armed rebellion, ensuring that fundamental rights are not fully suspended etc.
Further, when lessons are learnt hard way people and global community want to avoid any circumstances which led to that event. For example - the disasters impact of Nuclear Bomb on Hiroshima and Nagasaki has forced the global community to never resort to Nuclear weapons no matter how worse the situation is be it during 1962 Cuban Missile crisis or in current time of Russia-Ukraine war.
So, there is no doubt that present is shaped from lessons from past in hard way but why then we witness the instances like Israel-Hamas War, or countries not learning from debt trap policy of china?
Forgetting the Hard Way
There is a well known proverb that "those who don't learn from the history are bound to repeat it." This is evident from the continuous wars in Middle East, debt trap of china which we saw above. But why people don't learn from hard lessons of past?
One of the reason is the greed and lust of those in power. They try to gain from it because they think that violence will happen in 3rd country and their country would be safe. But they forget what Martin Luther King said - "Injustice anywhere is threat to justice everywhere". The Attacks of 9/11 on US is a testimony to that.
Another Reason is that there is crisis of visionary leadership at National and International level. The declining power of US and wolf-warrior diplomacy of china has led to Kindleberg trap and that is such situation prevents action which shapes future in right direction. The issues of UNSC reforms, constant struggle for dominance in Pacific, rising deglobalisation is a proof of it.
Thirdly, not everytime people forget the lesson. They might remember the lesson but they might not have the capacity to do something about it. The speech of Tuvalu President - "We are Sinking" shows that SIDS know about impact of climate change but they don't have the capacity to control it by acting alone.
Having seen the reasons why people forget the hard lesson of past and not act in the right way, it is pertinent to ask what is the way ahead.
Way Ahead
One of the way ahead is to ensure that right history is taught to the students so they are aware of the impacts of forgetting history.
Secondly, it is important to ensure that true model of democracy prevails in all institutions so that all voices can be heard. We need to remember that a mighty empire like Dhritarashtra had people within it like Bhisma, Vidur, Dronacharya but he decided to not listen to them.
Thirdly, reforms in the national and global institutions is important like UNSC reforms, WTO reforms. This will ensure that decisions in the interest of all could be taken.
On an ending note, we need to remember that world today is facing challenges of biodiversity loss, pollution, climate change, possibility of war over Taiwan, therefore it is important to learn from history otherwise humanity would have to pay the hard price.
In the dialogue which we saw, between Krishna and Bhisma would not be happening if Duryodhan had listened to people like Krishna and Bhisma and learnt from past like that of Ravana's end. His empire would be beyond his imagination. Therefore we must ensure, we not don't repeat the Same mistake.