The question of gender equality is central to the debate on uniform Civil Code. In this light what are the challenges in reconciling UCC with gender equality as enshrined in the constitution?
Prajnanandan Giri, AIR 24, 2023
Article 44 under Directive Principles of State Policy provides that the state shall endeavour to formulate an UCC throughout the territory of India.
UCC -> Question of Gender Equality 1. Can address the discriminatory provisions of personal laws like polygamy, Triple Talaq, Sati, Child Marriage etc. 2. Promote Right to Equality for women, as suggested by Supreme Court in Shayara Bano case. 3. Reduces ambiguity on laws like bigamy and inter-faith marriages (Sarla Mudgal case)
Challenges in reconciling UCC with Gender Equality 1. Perception as imposing of majority traditions on minorities like monogamy. 2. Against the spirit of Article 26 i.e. right to manage own religious affairs. 3. Opposition from minorities like tribals and religious minorities (Personal law boards) 4. Lack of consensus among citizens including women - who are suppressed from right to equality. 5. Against the spirit of diversity of India, as UCC promotes uniformity
Way forward - Adequate Jan Samvads -> Ranjana Desai committee in Uttarakhand - Starting with amendment in personal laws - Create conducive environment through awareness generation.
UCC can be a way to Gender Equality for all religions. However, a comprehensive participatory effort is required for its success.