Topper Copies

Constitution is a mere skeleton whereas constitutionalism is the soul of democracy. Discuss.

Prajnanandan Giri, AIR 24, 2023

Constitutionalism refers to the adherance to constitutional values and morality in the actions of executive, judiciary and legislative.

Constitution is a mere skeleton a. Constitution only mentions the provisions and goals/objectives of India as nation, such as, 1. Secular, Democratic country (Preamble) 2. Achieve social, economical & political justice (Fundamental rights and DPSP) 3. Promote equality and liberty etc.

However, the responsibility of various organs of government is to apply those and uphold constitutionalism.

Constitutionalism as soul 1. To uphold separation of powers as envisaged in Article 50 (eg) NJAC judgement of Supreme Court (SC) 2. Uphold fundamental rights vis-a-vis secularism and right to freedom of religion (eg) Sabarimala judgement to allow women into temple 3. Protection of freedom of speech (eg) Shreya Singhal judgement 4. Upholding Rule of Law and Equality before law (eg) Raj Narain case 5. Promoting federal principle with a balance between centre-states (eg) SR Bommai judgement

As BR Ambedkar said, the success of our constitution depends on the morality of those who operate upon the constitution, i.e. the Government.

Therefore, the primary objective of governance should be to uphold constitutionalism in every action.