After being posted as the District Development Officer (DDO) in a district dominated by tribal villages, I met with all the Block Development Officers (BDOs) to understand the region's specific problems. The primary issues identified were water scarcity, poor educational infrastructure, irregularities in the midday meal scheme, and non-existent roads. With a limited budget, I began planning solutions for these pressing problems. A few weeks after the BDOs meeting, I made a courtesy visit to the Superintendent of Police's (SP) office. During our cordial conversation, the SP mentioned witchcraft-related crimes, which surprised me as none of the BDOs had brought it up. My concern grew knowing that most victims of these crimes were women. A week later, while visiting a block for a routine inspection, I met with school teachers, ASHA workers, and women elders from Self-Help Groups (SHGs). Through discussions, I learned that witchcraft had deep roots in the community. ASHA workers reported incidents almost every month, though none were officially recorded. Realising the gravity of the situation, I decided to allocate part of the development funds to tackle witchcraft-related superstitions. Local NGOs and SHGs welcomed the initiative, but two weeks later, you received an RTI wanting an explanation for allocating funds for witchcraft-related issues at the cost of critical areas like education, roads, and water supply. (a) What are the issues involved in the above case? (b) With a limited budget at your disposal, you decide to allocate funds to tackle witchcraft-related superstitions. How would you justify your decision to the community and stakeholders? (c) Given that witchcraft-related crimes were not initially reported by the BDOs, how would you address this lack of communication and ensure better reporting and transparency moving forward?
Divyank Gupta, AIR 21, 2024
The given case study talks about the issue of witch hunting prevalent in some communities, especially the tribals, which take away lives of hundreds of women.
(a) Issues Involved in the Case
Stakeholders / Ethical Issues
1. Tribal villagers - taking away the lives of women - against the inalienable rights of the people (John Locke) - no value to life of people - making the witchcraft a norm - lack of apathy for the issue 2. BDO 3. SP - didn't do much about the witch hunting, shows laxity on his part - has no respect for human life - puts material interest above life of an individual 4. RTI activist - to show moral courage and courage of conviction - use persuasion and social influence 5. Me, DDO
(b) Justification to Community and Stakeholders
1. Life of a person is the most important as it is an inalienable right (John Locke) 2. Convince them through veil of ignorance of John Rawls that if they were in women's position, how would they feel 3. Funds for mid-day meal, infrastructure could be collected through crowd funds - eg Fund your city project of Radha Sabarwal 4. Extra funds can be asked from state under PM JANMAN, bringing private sector - eg Trifed by Facebook 5. But life is only once
(c) Addressing lack of Communication and ensuring better Reporting and Transparency
1. Make people aware about the laws for stringent punishment 2. Sympathise with the BDO about plight of women 3. If they are still inactive, then threaten them with inaction 4. Establish Mahila Chaupal (women meet) to discuss issues of villages so as to empower them and keep eye on such issues 5. Best practices - eg Lakshmipur village used social boycott method to counter witch hunting 6. Bring scientific temper through adult education under NEP 7. Flying squad and informers to keep an eye on such thing 8. CCTV cameras can be installed 9. Use of Nukkad Natak to sensitise villagers and officers
Further, taking example of Padma Shri awardee Chhutni Devi who saved lives of more than 100 women from witch-hunting would help in achieving justice to all.