Topper Copies

There is a need to resolve the ambiguity in the disqualification provisions under section 8 of the Representation of people Act 1951. Discuss.

Prajnanandan Giri, AIR 24, 2023

Section 8 under RPA Act 1951 provides for disqualification of a legislator for various reasons.

Ambiguity 1. 2 year jail term -> leading to disqualification -> If stayed conviction -> then reinstatement (However this provision is not mentioned clearly) 2. Practices like false affidavit, non-declaration of assets -> not declared as cause for disqualification. 3. No power to ECI to take strong action -> leaves it with Judiciary.

Way forward 1. Need to resolve the ambiguity with amendments in RPA 1951 2. Dinesh Goswami committee -> to include electoral offences and corrupt practices as cause of disqualification. 3. Clear provisions on jail-term and subsequent disqualification -> for stay/commutation of sentence 4. In this way, clear provisions are needed under RPA 1951 to prevent criminalisation of politics as per Lily Thomas case guidelines.